Gears of War 3 takes cover and squad play as far as the trilogy goes
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Everything runs through cover and the squad beside you
Critics read Gears of War 3 as one idea carried as far as it would go: a third-person shooter where you stay alive by using cover and leaning on your squad. Game Informer called it "a fantastic idea polished to near perfection," and the design backs that up. Nearly any structure works as cover. You can fire blind from behind it, or lean out to aim properly and expose your head while you do. You can also slide between nearby walls or vault low cover to push forward.
Health follows the same logic. There's no health bar. Taking damage fills a red "crimson omen" on the screen, and it fades if you get out of the line of fire. Take too much and you go down. An ally then has a short bleed-out window to revive you before you die or an enemy finishes you with an execution. Explosives and head shots skip that window entirely, and on Insane difficulty there's no bleed-out at all.
So the game asks one thing of you all the time: stay behind something, and stay near someone who can pick you up.
The third game sharpens the idea instead of changing it
The new features all serve that core rather than pulling away from it:
- Tagging. Mark an enemy and computer-controlled allies focus their fire on it, while human teammates see its location on their screen.
- Sharing. You can now hand weapons and ammo to allies in the middle of a fight.
- Breakable cover. Some cover falls apart after enough damage, which you can use to force enemies out into the open.
The smaller systems carry the same risk-versus-safety trade. You carry four weapons: a pistol, grenades and two primary guns. Reloading offers an "active reload": press the button inside a marked zone and you reload faster with harder-hitting rounds that slow charging enemies. Miss it and the gun jams, leaving you exposed. You can skip the gamble and reload at normal speed.
The risk with a game this focused is that cover-shooting becomes routine. Game Informer argued it doesn't, pointing to a "constantly shuffling deck of threats" that pushes players to try new weapons and tactics.
Co-op and multiplayer are where the idea pays off
A game built around reviving and supporting teammates makes the most sense with real people, and that's where critics were most enthusiastic. Giant Bomb's Jeff Gerstmann gave it 5 out of 5 stars and singled out a "bigger, better multiplayer suite." Game Informer praised its "smart approach to network play" and later named it Best Cooperative Mode of 2011.
Tagging and sharing ammo matter far more when the teammate is human, and Horde Mode lets players pass money to each other as well. An experience level carries across every mode, earned through kills, executions, revives and helping teammates, and leveling up opens special characters and weapon skins for multiplayer. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated the game for Outstanding Achievement in Online Gameplay.
The story is an ending, not a starting point
This is the third Gears of War game and the last in the original trilogy. Science fiction author Karen Traviss wrote the story. IGN called it "the spectacular conclusion" to the saga, and Gerstmann said it answers important questions about the nature of the Gears universe. Game Informer also enjoyed its "hilariously over-the-top" set pieces.
That praise comes from people who knew the first two games. The campaign is built as a payoff, so newcomers will get the combat in full but only part of the weight behind it. Starting with the first Gears of War is the better route if the story matters to you.
Even the lowest score in the record was an 8
The record shows broad acclaim: 91.49% on GameRankings, 91/100 on Metacritic, and a critic average of 8.8 computed from the critic aggregates. It took best shooter honors from IGN, G4 and GameSpot.
The one public fight was over praise that wasn't high enough. Eurogamer gave it 8/10, and Epic Games' Cliff Bleszinski said it upset him when critics rated Gears of War 2 higher. Destructoid and GamePro criticized his comments, with GamePro's McKinley Noble noting the review was "actually pretty favorable." When the low end of the debate is an 8, the question isn't whether the game is good. It's whether its brand of cover shooting is your kind of game.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Gears of War 3 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1050833 wikidata.org