Analysis · Ghost of Yōtei

Ghost of Yōtei's sword fights outclass its dated open world

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who finished Tsushima wanting more swordplay

Ghost of Yōtei is built for players who loved Ghost of Tsushima's duels and quiet exploration and wanted a bigger second helping. It's a standalone sequel from Sucker Punch Productions: a single-player action-adventure game for PlayStation 5, set in Ezo in 1603. You play Atsu, a mercenary hunting the "Yōtei Six," the group that killed her family sixteen years earlier.

Critics say it mostly works for those players. OpenCritic reported that 94% of critics recommended it, and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.8 out of 10. Reviewers praised the combat and the story. Their complaints were about the rest: side quests, pacing near the end, and an open-world design some called old-fashioned.

Every new weapon answers a different enemy

The biggest change is how fights work. Tsushima's stance system is gone. In its place is what the game calls a weapon counter system. Atsu starts with a single katana and later adds a yari spear, a kusarigama chain-sickle, a two-handed ōdachi and a pair of katana for dual-wielding. Each new weapon counters a particular type of enemy, so the arsenal is a set of answers rather than a ladder of upgrades.

Ranged options grow too. The hankyu and yumi bows return, joined by a matchlock rifle and a matchlock pistol. Disarming attacks can knock a weapon out of Atsu's hands or an enemy's, and dropped weapons can be picked up and thrown. A wild wolf Atsu befriends can be called in during combat or stealth.

Critics responded to all of it. GameSpot's Richard Wakling called the combat "fantastic," and Eurogamer's Chris Tapsell praised its "great swordplay." Combat is the strongest part of the game and the main reason to play.

A predictable revenge story that's told well

The plot is a straight revenge tale, and most reviewers thought that was fine. Wakling at GameSpot called it conventional but "well told," and IGN's Michael Higham came to the same view: predictable, but well executed. Polygon's Giovanni Colantonio found it more personal than Tsushima's story.

The weak spot is the last stretch. GamesRadar's Andrew Brown called it a worthy successor but said it struggled with pacing toward the end. VideoGamer's Tom Bardwell rated it above Tsushima's story while calling the pacing "questionable."

Ezo itself drew steadier praise, and Higham singled out the setting. The map is split into regions, each with its own enemies. Teshio Ridge in the north belongs to the Nine-Tails shinobi clan, and its cold lowers Atsu's maximum health. Oshima Coast in the south holds Lord Saito's best-equipped troops, many of them carrying firearms. The weather changes between snow, rain and aurora borealis. Atsu has the grappling hook from the start, so climbing and swinging along cliffs are part of getting around from the opening on.

Side quests are where it shows its age

If you want an open world that breaks from the usual formula, critics say this isn't it. Tapsell at Eurogamer was the harshest. He called the open world dated and the side quests "prehistoric," and he argued the story would have worked better as a linear action game. Even some positive reviews named the side quests as a weak spot.

Most of the side activities will be familiar. Hot springs, bamboo cutting and following foxes to shrines all return from Tsushima, and they still raise Atsu's stats. The new ones are sumi-e painting (replacing haiku), a gambling game called zeni hajiki, and learning songs on the shamisen, which also changes where the guiding wind points. Atsu can make camp almost anywhere to heal, cook meals for stat boosts, craft ammunition and trade with vendors.

There's plenty to do, but the record suggests the quality is uneven. The main story and the fights carry the game. Much of what sits between them repeats what Tsushima already did.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet