Analysis · Gloomhaven

Gloomhaven turns every attack into a card you may never get back

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every turn is a choice between two cards

Each round, every mercenary picks two cards from a deck built for their class. Each card has a top action and a bottom action. If you use the top of one card, you have to use the bottom of the other. Moving, attacking and looting all come from these cards, so you can't do something unless your hand allows it.

Each card also has an initiative number, and that number decides when your character acts compared with everyone else on the board, enemies included. Monsters follow the same rules, with their own initiative and set actions. That makes each round a question of timing as much as damage. A strong attack is no use if the enemy acts first and moves out of reach.

Your cards are also your clock: when a mercenary burns their last one, they're out of the fight.

Used cards go to a discard pile until the character rests. Resting brings the pile back but burns one card for the rest of the scenario, with a few exceptions for certain classes. A big play now leaves you fewer rounds later. Reviewers kept pointing to the game's difficulty, and this pressure is a big part of it.

Scenarios, the city and a slow climb

A run starts with a guild of two to four mercenaries. Six classes are available at the start, and more open up as the story moves forward. Each class's deck sets how it plays, so the guild you pick shapes every fight.

The play happens in separate dungeon scenarios. Each has a main objective, such as killing every enemy or surviving a set number of rounds. On top of that are side missions and a personal goal for each mercenary, which pay out in gold, perks or experience.

  • Leveling up adds new cards or improves existing ones.
  • Card enhancements add extra damage to an attack or more range to a move.
  • Trips back to the city between scenarios let you spend gold on items.

This loop is where the depth that PC Gamer praised comes from. A mercenary's deck changes over many scenarios, so choices you made several fights ago still matter in the next one.

Two campaigns, and they don't share a guild

Campaign mode follows the tabletop game. It covers the area around the city of Gloomhaven, with every scenario from the original board game and 95 missions. Guildmaster mode exists only in the digital version. It has 160 missions, a tutorial and a different progression system from the board game.

Both modes work solo or in co-op. Guilds and characters don't carry over between them, so time spent in one mode doesn't help you in the other. If you're new to Gloomhaven, start with Guildmaster for the tutorial. If you already own the board game and want the real campaign on a screen, go straight to Campaign mode. Between the two modes, the mission count is the game's strongest case for staying power.

The game spent two years in early access on Windows before its full release on October 20, 2021. It reached macOS on November 25, 2021, and Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X and Series S on September 18, 2023.

Where critics landed

Most reviews were positive, and most of the praise was about how well the board game came across. Rock Paper Shotgun called it a "loving and skillful adaptation." Polygon said the board game had been "masterfully translated to the PC" and named it one of the most satisfying turn-based dungeon crawlers of 2021. TheGamer liked how it looks and wrote that its "level of detail is astonishing."

PC Gamer's review gave the clearest warning. It praised the depth and the campaign but faulted the lack of quality of life features and noted occasional performance issues. The game was also nominated for Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year at the 25th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

The scores show the same picture. One aggregate lists 80/100 from eight reviews on each platform. Another lists 76/100 across 31 reviews as of March 18, 2024, with a 64% figure on the same date. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 7.8 out of 10.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet