Analysis · Go Vacation

Go Vacation gives families a big island and too many thin minigames

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for a family sharing one couch

Go Vacation is for households that want one game everyone can pick up, from a young child to a grandparent. It's rated Everyone and PEGI 3. Up to four people can play together locally, and the cast of 284 avatars is sorted into groups like "Grandmother", "Grandfather", "Boy" and "Girl". You can also play as your Mii.

The game spreads more than 50 competitive and co-operative activities across four resorts on the fictional Kawawii Island: Marine, City, Snow and Mountain. They range from bungee jumping and scuba diving to ice fishing, snowman building and miniature golf. For that audience it has real fans. Andy Robertson of Wired called it one of his "go-to family gaming suggestions" and "a real treat".

Critics as a group were less warm. Metacritic rated both versions "mixed or average", and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 6.7 out of 10.

The island itself is the strongest part

Critics praised Go Vacation most for moving around in it. The island is open to explore at your own pace, on foot or in vehicles that change by resort, and each resort has fast-travel points. In the Wii version, IGN's Audrey Drake found that traveling by marine bike, roller blades or horse was "engaging in its own right". Nintendo Power's Cody M. called exploring a "joy", even while criticizing the controls.

The villas give that wandering a purpose. After 20 minigames you get your own villa to decorate with furniture and photos taken during play. Furniture comes in 90 sets, found around the world or earned with silver keys, and gold keys change the outside of the house. Nintendo Life's Ryan Craddock compared it to the house decorating in the Animal Crossing series.

There's a catch. GameSpot's Chris Watters said the game doesn't explain how to earn those keys. The Switch version adds animal photography and reward boxes hidden around the resorts, which give younger players more to hunt for between events.

Lots of minigames, not much depth

This is where Go Vacation falls short. Most critics found the activities thin. Destructoid's James Stephanie Sterling called them "tepid and shallow", and Craddock described them as "undercooked" versions of familiar games. Watters was kinder, saying "most are decent", but he flagged an awkward camera and unresponsive controls in some of them.

Jeuxvideo.com's Anagund was the strongest defender of the sheer volume. The game does hide some of its depth, though. Winning some minigames opens harder modes, but Nintendo World Report's Daan Koopman said the Switch version never makes clear that more activities and modes become available after you first finish a minigame. Players who don't go looking can easily miss them.

For a family that wants variety for a few evenings, quantity is the selling point. For anyone who wants a sports game worth practicing, it isn't enough.

Why the Switch version is the one to get

The controls split the two releases more than anything else. On Wii, some minigames use the MotionPlus controller, the Wii Zapper, the Balance Board or the Wii Wheel. Critics found that setup clumsy:

  • Sterling disliked having to plug and unplug the Nunchuk when switching between minigames.
  • Cody M. called the motion controls "awkward" and said trying to move forward could turn you in the wrong direction.
  • Nintendo Life's Mark Reece blamed an "unintuitive control scheme" for minigames that weren't fun.

The Switch version, released July 27, 2018 in North America, Europe and Australia, fixed most of that. Koopman named the controls among the "biggest improvements over the original", and IGN Italia's Alessandra Borgonovo singled out the roller skates as fun to use.

Two complaints apply to both versions. The island's people barely react to you. Drake joked that everyone but you is "a robot", and Sterling called the NPCs "completely charmless". Reece also called the music "irritating and forgettable". Neither will bother a child much, but adults may turn the volume down.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet