Analysis · God of War II

God of War II keeps the combat and doubles the bosses

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A sequel that refines rather than reinvents

God of War II is the second installment in Santa Monica Studio's God of War series and the direct sequel to 2005's God of War. It came out on the PlayStation 2 on March 13, 2007, late in that console's life. As a sequel it plays things safe: Kratos is back, the combat is the same, and almost everything around the combat got bigger.

The setup turns Kratos from winner to target. He has become the God of War after killing Ares, until Zeus betrays him, strips him of his godhood and kills him. The Titan Gaia saves him and sends him after the Sisters of Fate, who can send him back in time to undo the betrayal. Vengeance drives this story, just as it drove the first game.

The core stayed the same on purpose. Many of the original's combo attacks return, and IGN's Chris Roper called the combat practically identical. He didn't count that against it, since it "was already perfect the first time out."

What the sequel actually changed

Most of the changes add more content or smooth out rough spots. The game has more than double the boss fights of the original and harder puzzles. It also sends a wider cast of mythological enemies at Kratos: harpies, minotaurs, Gorgons, cyclopes and Sirens, plus creatures made for this game, such as undead legionnaires and the army of the Fates.

  • Scale. GameSpot's Alex Navarro said some levels are "unbelievably massive," and Roper praised how many more kinds of environments there are than in the first game.
  • Movement. Roper said the original's small flaws were mostly gone. His example was faster wall climbing, including sliding straight down walls.
  • Magic. Eurogamer's Kristan Reed found the magic attacks more useful than in the first game.
  • Puzzles. These range from pushing a box into place for a higher jump to collecting items from several areas to open a single door.

Reed said the game's balance "always feels spot-on" and that its learning curve works for both hardcore and casual players. Exploring pays off with hidden extras. There are three Uber Chests, two of which make the health and magic meters longer. There are also hidden urns that grant abilities such as unlimited magic for bonus play after you finish the game.

The complaints are small, and most are about sameness

Most critics who found fault found the same one: the sequel didn't push the series forward. 1UP's Matt Leone said his only real disappointment was that the game didn't evolve the series. Navarro wished more had been done with the combat, which he found "overly straightforward" at times and still prone to button mashing.

The smaller complaints are specific:

  • Roper pointed to a couple of puzzles that were rough in execution, and he called the requirements for some bonus content "punishingly hard."
  • GameTrailers objected to invisible walls and to inconsistent navigation.
  • Navarro disliked the cliffhanger ending and some of the bonus challenges.
  • GameZone noted clipping, though it still called the game "unbelievably gorgeous."

Reed summed up the tradeoff: a sequel can't recapture the original's "wow factor," even when it turns out to be the better game.

Why it's remembered as the PS2's send-off

Critics praised the technical side almost without exception. Reed said he never saw a frame-rate drop, Navarro called the sound and graphics "superb," and GameTrailers said few PS2 games matched it visually. IGN and GameSpot both called it the console's "swan song."

The awards followed. It won PlayStation Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards, and at the BAFTA Video Game Awards it won Story and Character and Technical Achievement. In 2009 IGN ranked it the second-best PS2 game ever, five places above its predecessor. In 2012 Complex ranked it the best PS2 game of all time and rated it above God of War III. Critics liked the story too. Leone said the story is what makes it feel like "a true sequel," and Navarro liked that it's more about what happens around Kratos than what happens to him.

Its critic aggregate is 96/100 across seven reviews. The critic average of 9.6 out of 10 is calculated from those critic scores.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet