Analysis · God of War III

God of War III goes huge on scale but keeps the old formula underneath

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Huge in scale, familiar underneath

Critics agreed on what God of War III does best: size. IGN's Chris Roper said it "practically redefines" scale, and pointed to Titans bigger than whole levels in other games. The sharpest criticism took two forms. Official PlayStation Magazine UK's Mike Jackson felt the familiar core play kept it short of the very best. GameFront's Phil Hornshaw found Kratos so cruel that the game seemed to assume players enjoy the misery as much as he does.

Both points hold at once. Santa Monica Studio's 2010 PlayStation 3 game closes the trilogy with more spectacle than the series had tried before, built on a formula that had barely moved. Critics averaged 91/100 across 20 reviews, which gives it a critic average of 9.1.

Four weapons, one rhythm

Kratos fights from a fixed camera in combo-based combat against centaurs, harpies, cyclopes, minotaurs, Gorgons and more of Greek myth. He starts with the Blades of Exile and picks up the Claws of Hades, the Nemean Cestus and the Nemesis Whip. Each weapon now has its own magic attack, such as the claws' Soul Summon, and he can switch between all four mid-combo without breaking the chain.

That switching won praise. Eurogamer's Christian Donlan liked how easy it is to change weapons, and 1UP's Matt Leone said each one adds depth to the combat. GameSpot's Tom McShea said the brutal fighting stays one of the game's most satisfying parts, repetition and all. Roper was less sold: two of the three new weapons, he said, play much like the blades and are "more of the same."

The new moves help. The combat grapple pulls Kratos toward an enemy or shoves it away, and at certain points it lets him ride harpies across chasms. A simple grab turns weak enemies into battering rams. Between fights, you climb walls, swing on ropes and solve puzzles. Some only ask you to put an object in the right spot. Others test timing, including one built like Guitar Hero.

A story critics couldn't agree on

Zeus has betrayed Kratos, and the plot follows him up Mount Olympus in search of Pandora. He needs her to open Pandora's Box and bring down the Olympian gods. Reviewers were split on the story:

  • GameTrailers said it makes Greek mythology more interesting.
  • McShea said it starts slowly but turns "powerful and moving" near the end and gives the saga closure.
  • Donlan called it about as simple as a story can be.
  • Game Informer's Joe Juba found no standout revelations.
  • Hornshaw objected to a hero whose cruelty the game seems to expect you to share.

For some critics, the ending pays off. Everything before it is a revenge story with little room for anything else. If a vicious lead character bothers you, this entry will test that more than most. Its Mature 17+ and PEGI 18 ratings are earned.

The look is what won the awards

The visuals drew the least disagreement. Roper called Kratos perhaps the most impressive-looking character in games. Juba rated the camera work above Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, and Jackson put the graphics level with or ahead of Killzone 2. GameTrailers called the levels expertly designed.

The awards followed. It won Best PS3 Game and Best Graphics at the 2010 Spike Video Game Awards, Artistic Achievement at the 2011 BAFTA Video Game Awards, and Outstanding Achievement in Animation at the D.I.C.E. Awards.

Start with God of War II if you can

The game launched on PlayStation 3 in March 2010 and later came to PlayStation 4 as God of War III Remastered. Critics liked the remaster's smoother textures and better frame rate. Because the original already looked sharp, though, they called the gains minor and not enough reason to pay US$40 for it again. They also warned that the story picks up right where God of War II ends, which can confuse newcomers.

If you're new to the series, play God of War II first. Starting here drops you into a war that's already underway, and the payoff McShea praised at the end works better when you know how it began.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet