Gran Turismo 5 nails the handling but still races against zombie AI
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Brilliant physics, the same old rivals
Critics agreed on two things about Gran Turismo 5. IGN said its handling model "restores Gran Turismo upon the driving throne". IGN also called the computer drivers "the series' now trademark zombie A.I." The whole game sits between those two lines. Reviewers compared the driving model to real cars, but they said the opponents still brake unexpectedly and don't seem to know where your car is.
The praise covered more ground than the complaints, but the complaints kept coming up. Metacritic rated reception "generally favorable", and the critic aggregate sits at 89/100 across 18 reviews. The critic average of 8.9 is computed from that aggregate.
Why the handling won reviewers over
Polyphony Digital rebuilt the physics after Gran Turismo 4. Cars no longer snap into a corner the moment you steer. Weight has to load onto the outside wheel first, and heavy braking unsettles the car more than before. Car and Driver called the cars' behavior "startlingly faithful" to the real ones. Destructoid said that braking hard throws the car's weight forward in a way you can feel.
That realism cuts both ways. Car and Driver noted that the cars react to sloppy driving and to missed braking and turn-in points. Players who want a sim will like that. Players who want to pick up a controller and win will need patience.
A huge garage split into two classes of car
The game is big. It has 31 locations and 81 track layouts, up from 51 tracks in Gran Turismo 4. Real circuits include the Nürburgring, Circuit de la Sarthe, Suzuka, Monza and Indianapolis Motor Speedway, plus Top Gear's Dunsfold Aerodrome test track. Licensed World Rally Championship and NASCAR vehicles, karts and a course editor round it out. The editor builds tracks from settings such as the number of corners, the time of day and the number of sectors. GamePro called the amount of content "almost mind-boggling", and Destructoid said it took a full workday just to go through GT Mode's menus.
The catch is that the cars come in two tiers:
- Premium cars get detailed models and a fully detailed cockpit view.
- Standard cars don't have that cockpit, and reviewers said they looked like scaled-up Gran Turismo 4 models.
Update 2.02 let standard cars take aftermarket wheels, but the gap in detail stayed. Online racing drew less criticism. Reviewers said races ran smoothly without noticeable lag, and GamePro said the online mode gives the game "incredible longevity".
Stunning weather, shaky frame rate
The new weather and time-of-day effects got some of the warmest praise. Destructoid wrote about snow blowing across the windshield and night fog swallowing the headlights. CGMagazine pointed to raindrops on the glass in cockpit view. Photo Mode showed off the premium cars' detail.
Critics also reported frame-rate drops and screen tearing. Both were worst with a full grid on screen and rain or smoke in the air, which is exactly when the game looks its best. Sound held up better. PSX Extreme said the game "sounds fantastic" and that the reviewer's own cars sounded right. TweakTown found some engines flat. Gran Turismo 5 won Best Racing Game at the 2011 Golden Joystick Awards.
Damage that arrived half-finished
This was the first Gran Turismo with both mechanical and visible damage. Cars dent based on the speed and angle of an impact, and for the first time in the series they can roll over. Critics said that at launch, though, damage barely changed how a car performed. A later update added an option for full damage along with tire and fuel wear.
Weak damage and inattentive AI add up. Contact doesn't cost much, and the other cars don't race you so much as follow their line. The game is at its best as a driving sim, not as a race against the field.
Come for the cars and how they handle. Don't expect the computer drivers to give you a real fight.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Gran Turismo 5 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q773395 wikidata.org