Gran Turismo Sport bets everything on online racing and mostly wins
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Great handling, but you need a connection to keep progress
Eurogamer's Martin Robinson called Gran Turismo Sport possibly the "most focused, directly enjoyable" Gran Turismo since Gran Turismo 3. Ray Carsillo of Electronic Gaming Monthly gave it a 6/10 and attacked the other side of the same design: without an online connection you can't save, and only single arcade races are available offline.
Both critics are describing one decision. For this twelfth game in the series, Polyphony Digital built everything around competitive online racing, and nearly every strength and weakness reviewers found comes from that choice. Metacritic called the reviews "generally favorable", and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 7.8 out of 10.
Sport Mode is where the game earns its praise
Sport Mode runs three daily races, and the lineup resets every week. Every player carries two grades. Driver Rating measures skill, and Sportsmanship Rating measures conduct, such as avoiding contact and obeying flags. Both run from E at the bottom up to A+ and S, and your Driver Rating can never be higher than your Sportsmanship Rating. That rule means fast drivers who crash into people get held back. Balance of performance adjusts each car's weight and power so that cars in the same category stay close.
IGN's Luke Reilly called the result a "sturdy online racing venue". He said the Sportsmanship Rating isn't perfect, but over time it separates good drivers from bad ones and rewards clean, fair overtaking. Justin Towell of GamesRadar gave the game 4/5 and called the online modes its main selling point. In his view, winning a slipstreaming race on an oval against real opponents beat anything offline, and the real-world calendar made it feel like it "really means something".
That calendar goes further than most racing games. The FIA runs two championships inside the game: the Nations Cup, where players represent their countries, and the Manufacturers Cup, where they represent a car brand. Champions are honored at the FIA's annual prize-giving ceremony in Paris.
Fewer cars, and no weather to race them in
The online focus came at the cost of size. Robinson pointed out that the launch car list had no lunar rovers, no 19th-century wagons and no open-wheel racer. Jason Faulkner of Game Revolution counted only 17 locations at launch, with layout variations bringing the total to 40 circuits. IGN called the smaller garage and track selection impossible to forgive.
Unlike Gran Turismo 5 and 6, this game has no dynamic weather or day-night cycle, though you can set the time of day before a race. The content did grow later: as of July 2021, the game listed 338 cars and 82 layouts across 32 locations. It also brought Porsche into the series for the first time.
The driving itself was rarely in dispute. Carsillo called the handling "easily the strongest aspect" of the game. Faulkner thought you feel the cars' weight more than in Forza but still found something missing compared with Project Cars 2. Robinson also praised the improved sound and a livery editor that lets players design paint schemes and share them online.
Offline players get the short end
The sharpest complaints were about what happens without a connection. Saving only works online, and most features are unavailable offline. Carsillo concluded that anyone hoping for a traditional Gran Turismo would be disappointed. Faulkner regretted the lost single-player content, since the online mode, however well made, can't be used when the servers can't be reached.
Some single-player content survives in the form of scenario challenges that Towell found educational. He also called them "pedestrian" and said they were nowhere near Forza 7's career mode. He guessed the always-online requirement was there to watch for cheaters, but he still counted it as an inconvenience.
The rule of thumb: if you'll mostly race other people, the trade-offs barely matter. If you'll mostly race alone, they're the whole story.
Award voters leaned toward the first group. Eurogamer ranked the game 21st in its top 50 games of 2017, Game Informer's readers voted it second for best racing game, and IGN nominated it in the same category.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Gran Turismo Sport en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21563294 wikidata.org