Grand Theft Auto V's heists won critics over, but Trevor split them
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Trevor is where the critics parted ways
Critics agreed on almost everything about Grand Theft Auto V except the people at its center. The story follows three criminals: retired bank robber Michael De Santa, street gangster Franklin Clinton and drug dealer Trevor Philips. Reviewers were polarized by that story and those characters, and most of all by Trevor.
GameSpot called Trevor "horrible, terrifying, psychotic" and still a terrific character. Eurogamer went the other way and found him "shallow and unconvincing". It argued that his eccentricities hurt the narrative and pushed aside Michael's and Franklin's development.
The complaints went beyond one man. Some reviewers ranked the plot below Grand Theft Auto IV and Red Dead Redemption. Joystiq found the leads hard to like and described the feud between Michael and Trevor as a "seemingly endless cycle". The Escapist struggled to connect with characters driven by greed, with nothing to make a player want them to win. On the other side, some critics said the clash of three personalities tightened the pacing. GamesRadar thought the game cleared away the muddled morality of earlier entries.
The split is really about whether you need someone to root for
Nobody on either side called the writing lazy. The argument is over sympathy. Some players are happy to follow three awful men through a crime satire because the spectacle and the bite are the point. Those players are probably closer to GameSpot, and Trevor may end up being their favorite part. If you need a lead whose choices you can care about, the reviewers who missed Grand Theft Auto IV's plot are describing your experience.
This matters less than it would in a tighter game. After the opening prologue the whole map is open to explore, so the story is one thread among many. The way critics' praise was spread out supports that reading:
- If the characters work for you, you get the full package, and the critic average reflects that.
- If they grate, you still get the heists, the city and the driving that most reviewers rated highly.
- If you came for a moving crime story, Eurogamer, Joystiq and The Escapist are the critics to listen to.
The heists show why three leads beat one
Outside missions, a compass on the screen lets you switch between the three men at will, and some missions switch for you to finish an objective. Critics were close to unanimous that this works. Edge noted that switching cuts out long drives to mission start points. Game Informer said it keeps you "in the thick of the action" during shootouts. Eurogamer found it added tactics, because characters posted at different vantage points made fights feel less like a shooting gallery.
The heists are where this pays off. You bring in AI accomplices with skills such as hacking and driving. Survivors take a cut of the money and come back better at their jobs. Some heists offer more than one approach: one holdup can be done quietly by knocking out civilians with an incapacitating agent, or loudly with guns drawn. Giant Bomb welcomed the break from the series' usual mission structure. GameSpot pointed to the 1995 film Heat as an influence on their style. Polygon compared fast switching during a heist to film editing, with the player choosing the best angle for each moment.
Los Santos carries the game even for its doubters
The city of Los Santos, based on Los Angeles, drew the broadest praise. Reviewers liked how it condenses that geography into a well-designed space and how sharply it satirizes modern American culture. Edge praised the graphics and the absence of load screens. Eurogamer called the lighting the biggest step forward. Official Xbox Magazine was surprised the Xbox 360 could run it at all.
Moment to moment, critics found it better built than earlier entries. Game Informer said cars have "a proper sense of weight" without losing agility in traffic. Most reviewers found the shooting tighter. Some welcomed mid-mission checkpoints as the fix for a long-running series frustration. Destructoid called the sound design "impeccable".
Destructoid was the clear dissenter on combat, calling auto-aim "twitchy and unreliable" and the cover system dated and unwieldy.
That leads to a simple rule. Trust the 9.4 critic average, which is computed from critic aggregates, for the world, the heists and the craft. If you already know you need a likable lead, give the dissenting critics extra weight before you start.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Grand Theft Auto V en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17452 wikidata.org