Analysis · Graveyard Keeper

Graveyard Keeper turns the cozy farm-sim loop into a job digging graves

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea: a farming sim where the plot of land is a cemetery

Graveyard Keeper is built on one swap. It's a management sim inspired by Stardew Valley and based on Harvest Moon, but you don't inherit a farm. You inherit a small graveyard near a village, overgrown with boulders, trees, stumps and weeds. An ordinary man has landed in a medieval-fantasy world, and the job of keeping its dead in order falls to him while he looks for a way home.

Everything else in the game hangs off that swap. Each section below asks whether the rest of the design supports it or just adds more to do.

Clearing the cemetery is the strongest stretch

The opening goal is concrete. You clear the ground, get the graveyard working again, look after the graves and the church, and bring in money and donations for the church coffers. That's the farm-sim promise in its clearest form: a mess that slowly becomes tidy and starts paying for itself.

The graveyard theme earns its place here. Tending graves isn't decoration on top of farming. It's the main thing that brings in money, and it gives the game a gallows tone that cozy sims usually don't have. Lazy Bear Games, the studio behind Punch Club, clearly wanted a sim with some bite.

The way home runs through other people's errands

Your real goal is to open a portal back to your old world. To get there you need information and help from the townsfolk, which means keeping them happy and doing their quests. Those quests mostly ask you to bring crafted or gathered items, such as oil or honey.

This is where the core idea starts to thin out. A request for honey has nothing to do with the dead. The further you get, the more the graveyard turns into one station among many on a long supply chain.

Three colors of experience slow everything down

Progress runs through a skill tree the game calls the Technology Tree. New areas and systems open up as you research new technologies. After the early game, most technologies cost three separate kinds of experience: red, blue and green points.

  • Farming, smithing, fishing and a large crafting system all feed into the tree.
  • There's a multi-level dungeon, but the combat is basic.
  • New mechanics arrive slowly, spread out over the whole game.

Splitting experience three ways keeps you juggling several tasks at once. It also means a lot of time goes to gathering the right color of point rather than to the cemetery. That fits with how divided the critics were. One aggregate of 38 reviews from July 2021 sits at 65/100, a smaller tally of eight reviews reached 74/100, and a May 2023 count of 40 reviews came in at 30%. The critic average, calculated from those critic figures, is 7.0.

Where you can play it

The game first appeared as an alpha on Windows in May 2018. The full release came on August 15, 2018 for Windows, Xbox One, macOS and Linux. Nintendo Switch and PlayStation 4 versions followed on June 27, 2019, and a Japanese release on February 6, 2020. It's also out on Android and iOS. It's single-player only and rated Teen.

The graveyard is the hook. Whether you keep playing comes down to how much you enjoy the crafting chores around it.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet