Grim Dawn bets everything on old-school hack and slash, and mostly wins
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The scores agree, so the argument is about its retro design
Critics hardly disagreed about the number. The aggregate scores cluster at 82/100 for both the Windows and Xbox One versions, with one tally at 83%, and Metacritic sorted its 29 critics into "generally favorable." The real split is over what kind of game Grim Dawn chooses to be. PC Gamer's Leif Johnson laid out both sides in a single review.
Johnson said the game is held back by its "retro stylings." Its levels aren't randomized the way Diablo III's are, and he saw that as a limit on how much repeat play it can offer. In the same review he wrote that no recent competitor delivers old-style hack and slash "so purely and so satisfyingly."
What limits Grim Dawn and what makes it good are the same thing: it plays like an older action role-playing game on purpose.
If you want a fresh map every run, this will wear thin
The world is built by hand, so a second or third character walks through the same places as the first. Grim Dawn adds variety by stacking difficulty instead. There are three tiers, Normal, Elite and Ultimate, and you only reach each one by beating the base game's final boss on the tier before it.
There are extra dials on top of those tiers:
- Veteran makes Normal harder, with tougher monsters and bonus experience.
- Ascendent arrived in July 2026 with the Fangs of Asterkarn expansion and sharply raises enemy stats on Ultimate.
- Hardcore makes death permanent and destroys everything the character was carrying.
That suits players who enjoy running familiar ground with a stronger build. It won't satisfy anyone who judges a game in this genre by how different each run feels.
Where the variety comes from: two classes per hero
Johnson credited the hybrid class system with making each new run "a little different," and the game is built around it. There are ten classes. Six come in the base game (Soldier, Demolitionist, Occultist, Nightblade, Arcanist and Shaman), and four were added by expansions: Inquisitor, Necromancer, Oathkeeper and Berserker. Every character combines two of them.
Several systems add to that:
- Devotion gives you points for restoring broken shrines hidden around the world. You spend them on a large constellation map of bonuses and abilities.
- Crafting turns salvaged parts into items, then feeds those items into higher-tier recipes for stronger gear.
- Factions reward you with quest lines, discounts and special items. Siding with one can turn another against you, and hostile factions send elite hunters after you.
This is the game's answer to the criticism about fixed maps. The world stays the same, but how you approach it changes a lot from one class pairing to the next.
Who should pick it up
The setting is a dark world loosely based on the Victorian era. It runs on the Titan Quest engine, upgraded with dynamic weather, dismemberment, damage that depends on where a hit lands, and a camera you can rotate. You can play alone, in co-op or in multiplayer. Hardcore characters can only join sessions with other Hardcore characters, and they keep a separate stash.
It's a good fit for players who:
- miss the feel of older action role-playing games and don't need procedural levels
- like planning builds across two class trees and a constellation map
- want a permadeath mode with real stakes
The game and its DLC had sold 7 million units by February 2022, so this old-fashioned approach clearly has an audience. Before you buy, decide which side of Johnson's review you're on. If handmade levels with deep builds sound better than endless random maps, this is one of the purest versions of the genre.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Grim Dawn en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q5609186 wikidata.org