Guild Wars 2 cuts the grind out of the MMO and mostly gets away with it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The promise is an MMO without the grind
Guild Wars 2 rests on one idea: an online role-playing game shouldn't make you grind before you reach the fun. Critics at the August 2012 launch kept coming back to it. Computer and Video Games' Andy Kelly said it "combats the dreaded grind with smart design," and GamesRadar's Hollander Cooper praised it for removing "many of the gates" that had held the genre back.
The praise was close to unanimous. The game holds 90/100 on Metacritic. PC Gamer gave it 94%, IGN and GameSpot each gave it 9 out of 10, and Time named it the top video game of 2012. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.7 out of 10. The useful question for each part of the game is whether it keeps that promise.
Level scaling lets friends play together
The level cap is 80, up from 20 in the original Guild Wars. ArenaNet said that number left room for characters to grow without pushing players into a grind. In player versus environment, the game lowers a character's level and stats to match the monsters in an area. Difficulty stays even, so a high-level player can join a newer friend without flattening everything in sight.
Cooper called the ability to play with friends regardless of level or class "a gigantic leap forward." This is where the founding idea holds up best. IGN's Charles Onyett saw the same spirit across the game, describing one that "never unfairly penalizes" players and pays them generously for exploring.
Ten skills and no healer means fewer chores, but less room to build
Characters come from five races (humans, charr, asura, norn and sylvari) and nine professions, split into light, medium and heavy armor. There is no dedicated healing class. The developers thought that requiring a healer in every party was too restrictive, so every character carries its own heal.
Combat runs on 10 skill slots, and each slot has a set job:
- Slots one to five come from your weapon and profession.
- Slot six is always a heal.
- Slots seven to nine have no fixed role and open up as you progress.
- Slot ten holds an elite skill, which starts out locked.
That is narrower than the original Guild Wars, where players picked 10 skills from a much larger pool. The trade is deliberate. ArenaNet aimed for fewer, better skills and less splitting between game modes, which keeps balance easier to manage. Players who loved building odd combinations in the first game will have less room to do it here.
GameSpy's Leif Johnson summed it up fairly: the game "doesn't overthrow the conventions" of the genre, but it presents them in fresher packaging.
PvP puts everyone at level 80
In player versus player, everyone fights at a fixed level 80 with access to almost all skills and items. Hours played don't buy an edge. Small, tactical matches run alongside World versus World, which stages large battles in a persistent world separate from the main one. Players can drop in and out whenever they like, build siege weapons and earn rewards that match how well they do. Both modes fit the founding idea: skill and teamwork decide fights, not time logged.
Where the grind creeps back
A few systems work against the promise. Crafting has eight disciplines, but you can only practice two at a time, and switching costs a fee. Characters from the original game don't carry over, because Guild Wars 2 is set 250 years later. Linking your accounts transfers only a small number of achievements and honors.
The later endgame is harder to judge from the launch reviews. The Heart of Thorns expansion added raids that test a squad's coordination, damage output, positioning and builds. Strike Missions and tougher Challenge Mode encounters came after. That is demanding group content, the kind the core game set out to make optional, and the 2012 critic scores don't cover it. The main story follows the guild Destiny's Edge against the Elder Dragons and runs across several expansions, ending in End of Dragons (2023).
The game is free-to-play on Windows and macOS. Even at launch, Kelly noted that having no monthly subscription fee "only sweetens the deal."
Sources
- Wikipedia: Guild Wars 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q484907 wikidata.org