Hades makes every failed escape count, and critics barely found a flaw
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The one argument critics had was about the fighting
There wasn't much disagreement to find. Metacritic called the reception "universal acclaim", OpenCritic found 99% of critics recommending it, and the aggregates sit at 93 to 94 out of 100 on every platform listed. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 9.4.
The clearest point of friction came from Game Informer's Matt Miller. He called the combat "fast-paced and challenging" and praised the range of enemies Zagreus faces, but felt it could fall back on button mashing at certain points. That's the split worth taking seriously, because combat is most of what you do here.
Read next to the rest of the praise, the complaint is narrow. Critics singled out the story, the characters, the art and the soundtrack far more often than the moment-to-moment fights. So the question is whether the fighting has to be deep the whole way through for you, or whether it can be the engine that moves a story forward.
How the combat works, and why it can feel samey
Zagreus, prince of the Underworld, is trying to escape his father Hades and reach his mother Persephone. Each attempt is a run through rooms drawn from fixed layouts, with the order and enemies randomized, viewed from an isometric angle.
The toolkit is compact:
- a primary attack and a special tied to your chosen weapon
- a ranged magic cast
- a dash that briefly makes you intangible and can phase through thin walls
- a summon that calls on one of the gods
Variety comes from Boons, gifts from the Olympians that each offer a choice of three boosts for that run. Zeus's lean on lightning damage; Poseidon's push enemies back with waves. A run's character depends heavily on which gods show up. When the Boons line up, attacks pile on extra effects, which is likely where Miller's button mashing note comes from: a strong build can make careful play less necessary.
Dying is the point, and that decides who sticks with it
Lose your last death defiance and the river Styx carries Zagreus back to the House of Hades. You lose obols and some upgrades, but other currencies buy permanent improvements, new weapons and new features that show up in later runs.
The House is also where the story lives. Talking to characters such as Sisyphus, Eurydice and Patroclus improves Zagreus's standing with them and opens up quests. Destructoid's Jordan Devore praised dialogue that uses the game's non-linear structure "without coming across as artificial", and IGN called the cast an "authentic reinterpretation" of Greek myth.
Each death adds to the story, so the repetition reads as progress instead of punishment.
That structure is why players who usually bounce off roguelikes may stay. It's also the real cost. You will clear Tartarus, Asphodel, Elysium and the Temple of Styx many times, fighting the same bosses (the Furies, the Lernaean Hydra, Theseus and Asterius, then Hades himself) on the way to seeing it all.
How high the ceiling goes
Players who want depth from the combat have it. GameSpot's Suriel Vazquez pointed to a postgame with "even more reasons to play", and the game drew a large speedrunning community thanks to its replayability. In August 2023, a speedrun beat the game on maximum difficulty, something previously thought to be impossible.
The awards line up with that. Hades won Game of the Year at the British Academy Games Awards, the D.I.C.E. Awards, the Game Developers Choice Awards and the New York Game Awards, and it was the first game to win a Hugo Award. It's single-player only and rated Teen and PEGI 12, and it runs on Windows, macOS, Switch, PlayStation 4 and 5, and Xbox One and Series X and Series S.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Hades (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q59756366 wikidata.org