Analysis · Half-Life

Half-Life's brilliant Black Mesa run stumbles once it reaches Xen

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Xen is where the praise runs out

Critics agreed on almost everything about Half-Life except its ending. In the final stretch, Gordon Freeman leaves the Black Mesa Research Facility for the alien world of Xen, and reviewers generally called it the weakest part of the game.

The trouble is partly mechanical. Xen leans on low-gravity jumping puzzles, and the GoldSrc engine doesn't give much precise control in mid-air. A missed landing drops Freeman into a void and sends the player back to try again. Wired's Julie Muncy called the sequence "an abbreviated, unpleasant stop" with "bad platforming" and a boss that looked like a giant floating infant. The Electric Playground found the first half immersive and engaging but said the game "peaked too soon".

Nobody claimed the ending sinks the game. The complaint is narrower: it trades the game's main strength for a kind of challenge the engine wasn't built to handle.

What everything before it earned

The rest of the game drew some of the strongest praise a shooter has ever received. It holds a 96 out of 100 on Metacritic, and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 9.6. Computer Gaming World's Jeff Green called it the best single-player shooter since the original Doom. IGN called it "a tour de force in game design", and GameSpot called it the genre's closest thing to a revolutionary step.

Immersion came up again and again. AllGame said it had changed an entire genre. Hot Games said its environments made everything else look "quite shoddy" by comparison. Gamers Depot called it the most immersive game it had played.

The awards and retrospectives back that up:

  • AIAS named it Computer Entertainment Title of the Year and PC Action Game of the Year.
  • PC Gamer named it the best PC game of all time in 1999, 2001 and 2005.
  • IGN wrote in 2013 that FPS history splits into "pre-Half-Life and post-Half-Life eras".
  • The Guardian ranked it the third-greatest game of the 1990s in 2021.

The split tells you who will love it

The design critics praised is about staying inside Freeman's head. Apart from one short cutscene, the story plays out in scripted scenes while the player keeps control. Freeman never speaks and is never seen. There are no separate levels: chapter titles flash on screen, and each map runs straight into the next, with only short loading pauses.

The puzzles come from the setting itself. You might cross a maze of conveyor belts, stack boxes into a staircase, or turn a valve to blast enemies with hot steam. Most boss fights are won by using the terrain rather than outshooting the boss. Security guards fight beside you, and scientists help open new areas.

If you want a place that feels real and puzzles that grow out of it, the first two thirds deliver what critics described. If imprecise jumping makes you quit games, know that the long jump module arrives late and Xen expects you to master it. Patience pays off here, because the frustrating part is short and comes last.

Which version to pick

The game launched on Microsoft Windows on November 19, 1998. Linux and macOS versions followed on February 14, 2013. A PlayStation 2 version came out on November 11, 2001, and got a cooler reception: Jeff Lundrigan rated it three out of five for Next Generation, though he said there was still "a surprising amount of life" in it.

The PC version is the one critics scored so highly, and it was one of the first mainstream games to use the WASD keys as its default controls. It also includes online deathmatch, both free-for-all and team-based. Expect plenty of violence: it's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 16, and its enemies include headcrab zombies, human soldiers and Black Ops assassins.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet