Analysis · Halo 5: Guardians

Halo 5's multiplayer won critics over while its story let many of them down

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The story is where critics split hardest

Critics fought over the campaign more than anything else in Halo 5. Engadget's Timothy J. Seppala called it the first Halo campaign in years that felt like a step backward from the game before it. Time's Matt Peckham said the plot felt "by the numbers" next to the marketing and the Hunt the Truth series, which had hinted at a new direction.

The complaints were specific. GameSpot's Mike Mahardy saw promise in the plot but said cutscenes end before they feel finished and characters change their motives without warning. Forbes' Paul Thier and GamesRadar's David Houghton both objected that players have little effect on how the story unfolds, and that the closing cliffhanger stops the plot at what amounts to the end of its first act.

The marketing made things worse. Phil Hornshaw of Digital Trends wrote that the ads promised an emotional clash between a possibly disloyal Master Chief and Locke, the Spartan sent to hunt him, but that those moments are "barely in the game." 343 Industries later said it had heard the complaints about how little Master Chief appears and would put more focus on him in the future.

Not everyone came down against it. IGN's Brian Albert found Cortana a more interesting threat than earlier villains, with motives "less black and white," and liked how background chatter fills in each character. In a 2022 retrospective, Game Informer called Halo 5 the most controversial game in the series. The story is a big reason why.

Almost nobody argued about how it plays

The shooting is the part critics agreed on. Players can now sprint without a limit, boost sideways with a thruster pack, slide, charge into enemies and climb up ledges. Every weapon can be aimed down a zoomed view, and zooming in midair lets a player hover briefly or slam into the ground below. Albert called it "the strongest combat Halo has ever seen." Polygon's Arthur Gies wrote that the studio brought the series' mechanics into the modern era by going back to its basics.

GameSpot said the multiplayer was in the "best shape" it had ever been. It liked that everyone starts a match with the same weapons and that stronger guns appear on the map, instead of being earned through unlocks as in Halo 4. Classic four-versus-four modes like deathmatch and capture the flag are back, and ranked play sets a skill rating through placement matches.

The new idea is Warzone, a 24-player mode where two teams fight each other and computer-controlled enemies while holding points on a large map. A match ends when one team destroys the other's base or reaches 1,000 points. GameSpot called it one of the best new ideas in the series and in the genre, a mode that rewards teams that can adapt over the course of a match.

The co-op campaign is better with friends than with bots

The campaign is built for four. Both Master Chief and Locke travel with a full squad of Spartans, Blue Team and Fireteam Osiris, and in co-op other players take those roles. Albert pointed to levels packed with secret routes and hidden weapons, which he said make the campaign worth replaying and well suited to co-op.

Played solo, the AI squad is the weak spot. Destructoid's Chris Carter found the squad commands basic, though he liked the team chatter and the help. Carter and GamesTM both reported teammates failing to revive them, even when standing right beside them. GamesTM also criticized overpowered bosses and said the number of ways to die instantly, even on Normal, is "exasperatingly high."

Two catches before you buy

  • No couch play. Halo 5 is the first main Halo shooter with no split-screen co-op, no split-screen multiplayer and no local network option. Every multiplayer session runs over Xbox Live.
  • REQ packs cost real money if you want them to. Warzone lets you call in weapons and vehicles based on cards from REQ packs. You can earn them by playing, or you can buy them.

Forge, the map editor, adds new controls and scripting tools, which gives players who build maps a reason to keep coming back. Critics who praised Halo 5 mostly praised its systems, and the people it disappointed mostly came for the story. GamesTM called it "sheepish and safe," while Carter thought longtime fans would still be satisfied. The aggregate shows how those views balance out: 84 out of 100 on Metacritic from 101 reviews, and a critic average of 8.4, calculated from those critic aggregates.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet