Happy Home Designer turns Animal Crossing into a decorating job with no town
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The job is designing rooms for picky animal clients
In Happy Home Designer, you work for Nook's Homes. An animal villager comes in with an idea for the home they want, and you build it. You pick the furniture, place it and arrange each room around the client's request. As you finish more jobs, more furniture becomes available to use in later designs, and you can go back and visit the homes you've already built.
That loop is nearly the whole game. The main series is a life simulation about neighbors, daily routines and a town that changes over time. This spin-off pushes most of that aside so house design can take center stage. IGN's Kallie Plagge praised the "freedom to be creative" that comes with this focus. GameSpot said the game fixes the "clunky design controls" from New Leaf, so placing furniture is easier than it was in the main game.
Plenty to place, little to push against
Critics agreed the game has a lot of content. Nintendo Life called the "sheer volume of content" staggering, and GameSpot described the new items as a "glut." If you enjoy flipping through furniture and fitting pieces into a room, there's more here than in any earlier game in the series.
The criticism came from the same place. Nintendo Life faulted the "lack of any real challenge." Clients ask for a style of home, you deliver one, and the game has little way to tell a great design from an average one. Plagge also said the game sometimes felt unrewarding. Without goals or stakes, your sense of progress mostly comes from getting new furniture, and how long that keeps you playing depends on how much you like decorating for its own sake.
Critics missed the town most of all
The harshest reviews came from critics who missed the parts of Animal Crossing this game leaves out. Game Informer's Jeff Cork gave it a 5 out of 10. Cork wrote that it goes much further into home design than the series usually does, but does it "without the town elements" that made the series a success. GameSpot also gave it a 5 out of 10 and said the town "feels barren" no matter how many homes you design.
GameSpot's point, in short: this would have been a great add-on for New Leaf, but it was sold as a standalone game.
That reading explains the split in the scores. Critics who judged the game as a design tool liked it. Critics who judged it as an Animal Crossing game found it empty.
Extras for New Leaf owners and card collectors
Happy Home Designer connects to New Leaf through the Nookling Junction kiosk, where you can get exclusive furniture for the older game. For players who still visit their New Leaf town, this is a concrete reason to own both.
The game also works with Animal Crossing Amiibo cards. When you scan a card, that character can visit a home you've designed. Cards also let you design homes for major series characters such as K.K. Slider and Tom Nook. If you collect the cards, this feature adds more clients and gives familiar characters a role.
The numbers match the mixed reviews: 66/100 on Metacritic, and recommendations from only 16% of critics on OpenCritic. The critic average of 6.4, calculated from those critic aggregates, lands in the same place. The game is competent and well stocked, but most critics said it was too narrow to stand on its own.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q19749315 wikidata.org