Analysis · Fantasia: Music Evolved

Harmonix's Kinect take on Fantasia charmed critics and wore them out

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Charm on one side, sore arms on the other

GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd called the game "overflowing with charm" and said it made the player feel like a performance artist, a sorcerer and a musician at the same time. That's the strongest praise on record. The sharpest criticism came from GamesRadar's Ashley Reed, who liked the songs and remixes but found the levels forgettable and the story weak, and kept running into trouble with the Kinect reading certain movements.

Polygon's Griffin McElroy landed between the two with a 7/10. The review praised the core mechanics and the sense of owning the music, but called the play exhausting and noted there's no difficulty setting. Critics agreed the idea works. Where they split was on the camera, the extras layered on top and how long a body can keep it up.

You conduct the song instead of following it

Harmonix built this motion-controlled rhythm game for Disney Interactive Studios, and it came out in 2014 for the Xbox 360 and Xbox One with Kinect. It's the interactive successor to the 1940 film Fantasia and Fantasia 2000, and the narration borrows from "The Sorcerer's Apprentice": Yen Sid takes you on as his apprentice and asks you to bring his empty worlds to life.

You do that by moving in time with licensed pop and classical tracks. Accurate gestures open up choices that change the composition, such as rock, orchestral or brass overlays laid over the original song. The Kinect shows you as an on-screen silhouette that changes objects it touches, and the game reacts to how you move, not just whether you hit the mark.

  • You can't fail or lose a level, though there are goals to complete.
  • Points come from timing, and switching tracks builds a streak and multiplier.
  • Magical energy earned in play buys items to bring into levels.
  • There's a two-player co-op mode, plus a party mode with every available song.
  • Finished mixes can be shared on the game's official YouTube channel.

What critics agreed on: control and remixes

The remix system drew the most consistent praise. IGN's Miranda Sanchez pointed to a "surprising amount of control" over each song and called the result a fresh style for music games. Joystiq's Susan Arendt (8/10) said the remixes extend the life of every track, and also praised the animation and the distinct personality of each location.

Several outlets liked the motion controls themselves. Hardcore Gamer's Steve Hannley (4/5) commended the visuals, the remix quality and the Kinect interaction. Destructoid's Chris Carter called the controls flexible and intuitive and liked being able to change a level's theme on the fly.

The more freedom critics had over a song, the more they liked the game.

Where it stumbles: spells, extras and stamina

On detection, the reviews genuinely conflict. Destructoid and Hardcore Gamer found the Kinect responsive, while GamesRadar reported ongoing problems with certain movements. If your room or camera setup already gives you trouble with Kinect games, expect GamesRadar's experience rather than Destructoid's.

Two features drew fire for getting in the way. Joystiq said the composition spells needlessly break up the core rhythm game. Polygon called the system for earning items and extras unnecessary. Neither complaint touches the music, but both add friction between you and it.

The physical cost is the con most likely to decide it for you. Polygon found the play exhausting, and with no difficulty setting, you can't scale the effort down. Because you can't fail, short sessions are an easy fix for that.

What the scores add up to

Metacritic lists 77/100 from 48 reviews. Another aggregate of 44 reviews shows 81/100 and 79%, and a smaller count of six reviews per platform gives 83/100 on both the Xbox One and the Xbox 360. The critic average of 8.2 is computed from those critic aggregates. No outlet in the record scored it low, and the lowest named score, Polygon's 7/10, still praised the core idea.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet