Analysis · Hearts of Iron IV

Hearts of Iron IV kept the war and rebuilt the economy that feeds it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The fourth Hearts of Iron, and the first to sell a million

Hearts of Iron IV is the fourth installment in Paradox Development Studio's grand strategy series and the sequel to 2009's Hearts of Iron III. It came out on June 6, 2016, for Windows, macOS and Linux, and it became the series' breakout. It sold more than 200,000 units in its first two weeks and passed 1 million in May 2018. No Hearts of Iron game had done that before, and only Crusader Kings II and Europa Universalis IV had done it among Paradox titles.

Critics mostly agreed the attention was earned. Metacritic filed it under "generally favorable reviews", and the critic average of 8.0, computed from critic aggregates, lands in the same place. Years later it still pulls a crowd: in 2022 it hit a concurrent player record of about 70,000 during a week when it was temporarily free to play.

What stayed: any nation, two start dates, one war

The core promise is the series' own. You pick any nation in the world and start on 1 January 1936 or 14 August 1939, in single-player or multiplayer. Polygon liked how far that goes, pointing out that you can take Venezuela, with two army divisions and 12 fighter planes, and see what happens.

The map works as a strategy board. Land is cut into small provinces grouped into states, while seas and skies are split into strategic regions with their own weather. Whether a division wins a fight depends on a long list of factors:

  • the quality of its equipment and the skill and traits of its general
  • terrain, weather and the air war overhead
  • supply lines and organisation
  • its soft and hard attack against what it faces

You build those divisions yourself from infantry, tanks, cavalry, motorized and mechanized battalions. That detail is the draw, and it is also why IGN said mastery could take "hundreds of hours".

What changed: factories, political power and a front line you draw

The economy is where the game asks the most of you. Civilian factories build the military factories and dockyards that make your equipment and ships, and they also produce consumer goods and handle trade. Most nations start with many of those factories tied up in consumer goods, and they free up only as the country mobilizes. Laws on mobilization, conscription and trade cost political power, an abstract resource that also pays for new ministers.

PC Gamer called it a "unique, beautiful, thrilling wargame" and singled out the frontline system and the production mechanics. IGN praised its "unusually striking look" and a clean interface that put the hard choices in strategy rather than menus.

The game has also kept changing since launch. With the expansion No Compromise, No Surrender, every factory needs power from coal. Arms Against Tyranny added a global arms market and military industrial organizations that improve equipment over time. Designing your own tanks, planes and ships requires certain DLCs, so the full game is a moving target and the base version is a leaner one.

Where critics pushed back

The praise came with consistent warnings.

  • Learning it. GameSpot called the tutorial the only weak point. Kotaku found it "overwhelming" in its complexity and said newcomers might find the interface too hard to use. IGN disagreed about the interface, so reviewers were split on whether the screens or the systems are the real barrier.
  • Late-game performance. IGN's biggest complaints were nearly all about performance, which it said gave the campaign a slow ending.
  • Smaller systems. PC Gamer found the ideology system bland and combat somewhat unintuitive.

GameSpot's take: for the dedicated, it "could end up being the best grand strategy game in some time."

The game also carries baggage outside its design. A 2022 study by the Global Network on Extremism and Technology found a minority of anti-semitic and Nazi-sympathetic posts in the r/HOI4 subreddit, though they were suppressed and most comments were apolitical. Kotaku reported in 2018 that several popular mods drew extremist comments, while some, such as Millenium Dawn, removed them. China banned the game on 2 November 2017.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet