Analysis · Hollow Knight

Hollow Knight earns its brutal bosses with a kingdom worth getting lost in

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A masterpiece to one critic, occasionally unfair to another

The strongest praise on record is about as strong as praise gets. Jed Whitaker of Destructoid called Hollow Knight a "masterpiece of gaming", and Tom Marks of PC Gamer called it a "new classic". The sharpest criticism came from Vikki Blake of Eurogamer, who found it "ruthlessly tough, even occasionally unfair".

Those two views don't cancel out. Most critics agreed the game is hard and decided that was part of what makes it good. Of the critics OpenCritic counted, 97% recommended it, and the critic average, computed from 10 critic scores, is 8.8 out of 10. Metacritic rated the Nintendo Switch version as "universal acclaim" and the PC, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions as "generally favorable".

Combat that starts tricky and rewards patience

You play a silent insect warrior armed with a sword-like Nail, plus spells for attacking from range. Health is a row of masks. Hitting enemies fills a Soul Vessel, and you spend that Soul either to heal by holding a button to Focus or to cast offensive spells. That one meter makes every fight a choice between healing now and dealing more damage.

Critics described the system as simple on the surface with real depth underneath, and they singled out how responsive it feels, in combat and in movement alike. Marks, writing for IGN, said the combat "starts out tricky" but rewards "patience and skill massively". Destructoid and Nintendo World Report both described a real sense of accomplishment after beating hard bosses.

Charms with no single right answer

Charms are equippable boosts, found or bought from characters around the kingdom. Each one takes up a set number of limited slots called charm notches, so you can't wear everything. Some lengthen your Nail's reach, and others make Soul easier to collect.

This was one of the most praised parts of the game. Marks called the system "brilliant" on PC Gamer and said he never found a right answer when equipping charms. Adam Abou-Nasr of Nintendo World Report said that removing one felt like giving up part of yourself for a better shot at the next fight. That tension, where every build costs you something, is why the system holds up across a long game.

Dying costs you, and that's the point

Lose all your masks and you drop all your Geo, the main currency. A Shade appears near where you died, marked on the map, and your Soul capacity shrinks until you go back and beat it. Die again before you do, and that Shade and its Geo are gone for good.

Critics compared this to the Dark Souls series. Destructoid liked it, arguing that it and the hold-to-heal button solve two old problems: how to punish failure fairly and how to build risk and reward into every fight. Not everyone got there right away.

Abou-Nasr wrote in his notes that the game was so frustratingly hard he couldn't recommend it, then said it "eventually clicked".

Whitaker went the other way and said he never found a boss unfair. Expect your own experience to fall somewhere on that line. If you beat the final boss, a Steel Soul mode opens up where death is permanent and wipes the save slot.

A kingdom you're free to leave half-explored

Hallownest is a fallen underground kingdom hit by a supernatural disease, split into large connected areas that each have their own theme. The game doesn't push you down one path or make you see everything. You can reach the end and still miss whole places.

Progress comes from new movement abilities: a double jump, wall-clinging and wall-jumping, and a dash. Some of these are rewards for beating bosses. Stag Stations, reached by riding a giant stag beetle through a tunnel network, handle fast travel once you've opened them. The story is mostly told through bug characters you meet and lore scattered around the world.

IGN credited the visuals, sound and music, along with "a million other details", with building the game's atmosphere. The game also picked up awards, including PC Gamer's Best Platformer of 2017, and Polygon later named it among the best games of its decade.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet