Analysis · Horizon Forbidden West

Horizon Forbidden West turns every machine fight into a puzzle of parts

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every fight starts with a scan

The basic loop is hunting machines, and it's built around taking them apart. Aloy uses her Focus, an augmented reality device carried over from the first game, to tag a machine and scan it for weak points. Then she picks the tool for the job. Her bow is still the main weapon, with ammo types that do different work: acid eats through armor, while shock stuns. Hit a machine with the same status effect enough times and it's crippled for a while.

Knocking parts off is where fights turn. A detached component takes a big chunk of health with it and can remove an attack from the machine's moveset entirely. Sometimes Aloy can pick up a fallen weapon and turn it on its owner. New tools add to the plan: the Shredder Gauntlet throws serrated discs that tear off armor, and traps, tripwires and tethers can pin a machine to the ground.

Up close, Aloy can now chain spear attacks into combos. She can also hide in tall grass, lure enemies over and take them out silently. Game Informer's Kimberly Wallace called the combat "adrenaline-pumping." At GamesRadar, Sam Loveridge found the large machines challenging but rewarding to bring down, and IGN's Simon Cardy said the variety of enemies pushes players to use Aloy's whole kit.

More tools than the game knows how to teach

Progress comes from quests. XP raises Aloy's health and earns skill points, which go into six trees: melee, traps, ranged combat, scavenging, stealth and overriding machines. Playing well, with headshots on human enemies or by tearing off components, builds a meter for a heavy special attack.

Critics split on whether that growth feels good. Bill Lavoy at Shacknews called the gameplay the game's greatest strength and liked the range of options in the skill tree. Wallace found the upgrades unexciting, even though she liked the quality-of-life fixes. Several reviewers said the pile of new mechanics could feel overwhelming and that the game struggled to explain them.

Two smaller complaints come up often:

  • Climbing was called inconsistent.
  • Aloy keeps calling out hints during environmental puzzles. The critic Hetfield argued this took away the player's chance to explore and find their own way.

A beautiful west on a familiar frame

The setting is a post-apocalyptic Western United States, and critics loved it. Wallace praised its "constant sense of discovery" and called the game a "technical marvel"; Lavoy called the visuals "breathtaking." The sunken Las Vegas was singled out by some reviewers as one of the best places in the game. Cardy found the settlements lively and each tribe distinct, and reviewers said the side quests and activities were varied and filled in the world and its people.

The shape of that world is where praise cools. Matthew Gault at Vice said it repeats "what open world games have been doing for years." James Tucker at NME went further, arguing it would have been a fairly middling open-world game without its story. In practice, that means a long list of side content that critics liked, laid out on a map style most players will recognize.

The story aims higher than it lands

Aloy heads west to find the source of a plague that kills everyone it infects. Cardy praised the cinematics and said the story was strongest on the cast's personal drama and the politics between tribes. Dom Peppiatt at VG247 compared the structure to Mass Effect. Critics credited the performances and motion capture, and several saw the focus on characters as a clear step up from Zero Dawn.

Aloy herself divided reviewers. Some found her struggles relatable, while Eurogamer's Phil Hornshaw found her less interesting than the people around her.

The plot's direction drew the sharpest criticism. Hetfield wrote that it went "fully off the rails" and disliked the ending and villains, and Digital Spy's Ben Rayner called the turn to "hard sci-fi" baffling. Reviewers also warned that the constant callbacks to the first game can leave newcomers out of the loop.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet