Analysis · Hyrule Warriors

Hyrule Warriors splits critics on its combat but not on its Zelda fan service

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The real argument is about whether the fighting gets old

Critics mostly agreed about the Zelda side of Hyrule Warriors. Where they split was the combat it borrows from Dynasty Warriors: one hero cutting through huge crowds of enemies, mission after mission. Lorenzo Veloria at GamesRadar called that combat "unimaginative" and repetitive. Dan Ryckert at Giant Bomb found the missions basic and full of "mindless slashing."

Other critics looked at the same systems and saw something else. James Stephanie Sterling at The Escapist praised a "meaty combat system" and distinct styles for each character, calling the game a mad idea that should get old after an hour "but never does." Simon Parkin at Eurogamer argued that Warriors games are often unfairly criticized, and that this one rewards thoughtful, strategic play over raw combo strings.

Your long-term enjoyment, GameTrailers concluded, comes down to how much you like Dynasty Warriors or hack and slash games in general.

That's the most useful line in the whole debate, and it's the question to ask yourself before buying.

Zelda fans get what they came for either way

Nobody disputed the fan service. GameSpot's Miguel Concepcion praised Zelda fan service "from beginning to end," Destructoid's Chris Carter called the amount "staggering," and Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard said it isn't a true Zelda game but has plenty for Zelda fans to enjoy. IGN's Jose Otero said it made him feel powerful in a world he loves.

The references reach into the mechanics too, not just the cast list. An original take on Link fights with a sword, bombs and the spin attack. Enemy targeting comes back, and opening chests still pays off. The original story brings many Zelda characters together to stop Ganondorf from being resurrected, and each character's moves change with the weapon they carry.

A long tail of goals for players who like the loop

The game is built to be replayed. Beyond the story there's a lot to chase:

  • Legend Mode runs the main story.
  • Free Mode replays any story chapter with any character.
  • Adventure Mode spreads missions across a map based on the original The Legend of Zelda, with goals like beating a set number of enemies within a time limit or finishing with a specific character and weapon.
  • Challenge Mode, added by a launch-day update, asks you to collect as many rupees as possible in a set scenario.
  • 100 Gold Skulltulas earn character illustrations and upgrade the in-game apothecary.

Behind all of that sits the Bazaar, where you forge weapons, spend rupees on levels, brew potions and trade materials for badges. Defeated enemies drop weapon bags with random weapons and materials bags for powering up characters. Zelda figures add extra content such as new weapons.

This is where the repetition argument cuts both ways. If you like chasing upgrades, the game keeps handing you new targets. If the first hour felt samey, the extra modes are mostly more of the same.

Co-op works, with a visual cost

Two players can share one Wii U locally, one on the GamePad and one on a monitor. Destructoid was especially fond of the co-op modes. IGN flagged the downside: the GamePad player gets a lower resolution, and the game slows down.

The scores sit between those camps. Critic aggregates landed at 76/100 across 69 reviews and 70/100 across seven, and all four Famitsu reviewers gave it 9 out of 10, for 36/40. The critic average of 7.3 is calculated from those critic aggregates. It describes a well-liked game that never fully won over the critics who dislike the genre.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet