Analysis · #IDARB

#IDARB is a crowdsourced couch brawl that stumbles once it goes online

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

An experienced studio built this one from crowd ideas

#IDARB is a 2015 multiplayer sports platformer from Other Ocean Interactive, released first on Xbox One. It isn't a newcomer's first game. Wired pointed out that the studio already had years of experience making games before this one. What made #IDARB different was how it was made: its ideas came from a crowd, and the finished game shows it.

Critics had trouble even describing it. Its own press release called it a "chaotic 8-player eSport" inspired by Bomberman and Smash Bros. IGN's Mitch Dyer described it as part arcade game, part hockey, part basketball. Eurogamer's Daniel Starkey called it "an absolute farce", and meant that partly as praise. Critics also liked how much the crowd's ideas added. Wired added a fair warning, though: "ideas are only as good as the execution."

The ball game at its center is simple and deep

Under all the noise is a tight set of rules. Teams of up to four box-shaped players run and jump across platforms to shoot a ball into the other team's goal. A match runs four rounds and lasts about 10 minutes, always on the same map, with platforms in the middle, pits at the bottom and a center arena where the ball comes back after each goal.

  • A close shot scores one point. Longer shots score two, three or five, depending on distance.
  • Bouncing the ball off platforms earns bonus points, and three bounces gives a 3x multiplier.
  • A "burst of energy" knocks the ball loose and can block a shot or another player.
  • Passing and shooting use the same button.

That design earned the game's best reviews. GameSpot's Tyler Hicks said it proved a fantastic game only needs a solid core with depth, and he singled out the varied scoring. Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard saw enough of a skill ceiling for it to become a serious competitive game. Wired put it more simply: it's easy to pick up, and spectators have as much fun as the players.

The extras invite the audience onto the field

The bigger change is everything around the matches. Online games were built to take orders from outside. Tweeting at the game's account, @idarbwire, with a room code and a hashtag set off effects called hashbombs. The #light hashtag, for example, darkened the whole screen except for the ball. Twitch chat could trigger the same effects, and viewers could bet on live matches or on matches played by AI-controlled players.

Halftime brings minigames that parody Flappy Bird and Duck Hunt. After each goal an announcer drops jokes about obscure pop culture, the 1985 film Fletch among them. At the end of a match, whoever spins their controller's right thumbstick fastest is named MVP. There is also a sprite creator with QR code sharing, crossover character packs for Halo and The Walking Dead, a music maker, a logo designer, and more than a dozen real recipes from game developers.

Edge called it "raucous yet ridiculous, funny yet infuriating."

Not every critic liked all that clutter. Eurogamer felt the game didn't trust players to find their own fun, and said it "can be a lot more fun to watch than it is to play."

Team size and online play are where it falls apart

Critics disagreed about how many players make it work. Polygon's Griffin McElroy found anything above two per team "a bit inscrutable", saying that in four-on-four just finding your own character takes most of your attention. IGN argued the other way: with fewer than four players, the game "never quite catches fire." The safest reading is that it's at its best with a full room and a group that enjoys chaos.

Online play drew the harshest criticism. IGN called each match "a crap-shoot" because of latency, and Destructoid's Jason Faulkner reported "a ton of stuttering". Polygon called it a minor issue. Either way, lag dulls a game that depends on precise jumps and shots. Matchmaking made things worse, because you could only face as many players as were on your own console. IGN said that "neutered" online play.

Local play has its own gap. With an odd number of players, no AI teammate can even out the sides, which IGN said left one team unhappy every time. A single-player campaign exists, but Game Informer couldn't recommend #IDARB to anyone who doesn't want to play with other people.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet