Infamous 2 moves like a dream and fights like a chore for some critics
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for players who want the city to be the playground
Infamous 2 is for players who want an open city and a set of electric powers to cross it, and who care less about a tight story. It's a single-player, third-person action-adventure for the PlayStation 3, released June 7, 2011 in North America. It's also the sequel to the 2009 Infamous. You play Cole in New Marais, a city built on two islands, and nearly everything he does runs on stored electricity.
Players who want that get the best of the game. Players who come for the story get its weakest part.
Getting around is the reason to play
Cole climbs buildings, grinds along power cables and powered train rails, and hovers for a short time. Critics loved it. Eurogamer's Christian Donlan called the game "video games' true master of parkour", and even GameSpot's Tom Mc Shea, one of its harsher critics, said moving through the city was a pleasure.
The city drew praise of its own. IGN's Colin Moriarty found New Marais more alive than the first game's Empire City, and Game Informer's Andrew Reiner called it a "sightseeing marvel." Mc Shea pointed to its varied neighborhoods. Exploring pays off in practical ways, too. Hundreds of Blast Shards are scattered around the city, and each one raises how much electricity Cole can store. Dead Drops fill in the back-story.
There's one catch. Cole gets pulled toward objects as he climbs. Mc Shea and Giant Bomb's Brad Shoemaker both said this makes most climbing easier, but it causes frustrating moments when he grabs the wrong spot and you needed precision.
The fights split critics down the middle
Cole's powers range from simple electric bolts to large electric rockets, and he fights up close with a melee weapon called the Amp. Draining powered sources refills his energy and his health. Experience points from defeating enemies, healing citizens and finishing missions pay for stronger powers and new ones. Depending on your choices, Cole also picks up ice or fire powers from Kuo or Nix.
Reiner enjoyed the combat and called the encounters "amazing open-world superhero fights." Donlan said combat had improved since the original but still couldn't match the thrill of getting around. Mc Shea found many of the fights tedious and the pacing uneven. Shoemaker said enemies could still be overwhelming, just as they were in the first game.
The camera got the most consistent complaints. Moriarty called it "wonky", and GameSpy's Sterling McGarvey said the game needed better targeting because the camera couldn't keep up with the action. On the technical side, Donlan and Shoemaker both said the frame rate improved on the first game, though Donlan found the draw distance low.
If the first Infamous's fights worked for you, these are the same idea running more smoothly. If they wore you out, these will too.
Story and morality are the weak link
Cole starts out neutral on a Karma scale that runs toward Hero on the good side or Infamous on the evil side. Small acts move it, like helping an injured citizen or draining one for health. So do Karma moments, where the action pauses and you pick a good or evil option. Your Karma decides which powers you can get, how Cole looks, how citizens treat him and parts of the story.
Critics weren't impressed by the choices themselves. Mc Shea called the morality system "laughable", and GameTrailers said it never offered tough decisions. GameTrailers did add that the two paths make for dramatically different games, though. Shoemaker said the good and evil powers were better balanced than in the first game, and he saw morality mainly as a way into cutscenes and powers. A second run is worth it for the other power set, not for the dilemmas.
The story divided critics more than anything else. Moriarty called it "incredible", and Donlan found the endings "genuinely satisfying." Reiner found it confusing, Shoemaker found it scattered, and Mc Shea called it bland.
One feature is gone for good. User Generated Content, which let players build missions and share them over PlayStation Network, was called "great" by both Mc Shea and Reiner. It was discontinued on August 31, 2026, so anyone playing now gets only the built-in story and side missions.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Infamous 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24300 wikidata.org