Analysis · InFamous

Infamous makes lightning do everything, and the city remembers your choices

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One of the best on PS3, with missions that drag

IGN's Greg Miller called Infamous "one of the best PlayStation 3 games to date." Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell was much cooler. He called the missions where Cole must defend a moving target against waves of enemies "repetitive and overlong", and he argued that the electric powers are standard shooter weapons, such as a shotgun or a sniper rifle, rebuilt out of lightning.

The rest of the critical response backs up both of them. The core of the game is strong, and the problems sit in specific missions and in the technical polish. Published scores ran from 7/10 at the low end to 5/5 at the top. The critic average, computed from six critics' scores, is 8.5 out of 10.

Electricity is your ammo and your health

Cole MacGrath is a bike messenger who survives an explosion that levels several blocks of Empire City and comes out of it with electrical powers. Those powers do almost everything. A node meter on screen shows his stored charge. You refill it by draining power from street sources or from people, and draining also restores his health.

There are 16 powers. They range from a basic bolt that costs no energy to lightning storms that empty most of the meter. The game rewards using the environment, for example blowing up a generator next to a group of enemies. Being living electricity also has costs: Cole can't drive vehicles or touch water.

Giant Bomb's Brad Shoemaker said Sucker Punch had "nailed the basic gameplay elements." X-Play's Matt Kiel liked that hard missions push you to use every power while "generous" checkpoints keep frustration down. Bramwell's counterpoint is fair, though. If the powers are just familiar weapons, the challenge comes down to where enemies are placed rather than to anything new.

Karma changes how the city treats you

Cole's Karma runs from Guardian to Hero on the good side and from Thug to Infamous on the evil side. Small acts move it, such as healing an injured citizen or draining one. So do Karma Moments, where the action pauses and Cole lays out a good option and a bad one. Paired side missions lock each other out, so you can only take one of each pair.

The choices change more than a number on screen. Good Karma brings citizens into fights on your side. Bad Karma gets you pelted with rocks. Cole's appearance, parts of the story and the powers you can earn all shift with it. Critics found both paths fun, and they said the powers and Karma together made fights involve real decisions.

Switching sides partway through is allowed, but any powers you bought on the first path get locked.

Climbing the city is the standout

Cole climbs almost anything and can fall from any height without damage. Miller credited the game with the "most original city-traversal mechanics" of any open-world game, and he said the precision climbing avoided being a "frustration-fest". Some reviewers disagreed on one detail: Cole grabs onto ledges too eagerly, which makes careful jumps hard to line up.

The city is split across three islands, and each one opens up only after you finish its story missions. Critics liked how the side missions connect to the main plot. They also liked that the citizens' reactions keep reminding you of the choices you've made.

Slow start, uneven cutscenes, shaky frame rate

Reviewers warned that the opening hours are hard and could put some players off, because Cole is weak until his stronger powers arrive. The story gets better in its second half, helped by stylized cutscenes. Those scenes also make the stiff in-engine animation and the voice acting look worse by comparison. Miller found Cole's voice too gravelly.

The technical complaints are specific: no anti-aliasing, objects popping in, and frame rate drops when the screen gets busy. None of these come close to sinking the game, but they show its age and its budget.

Infamous launched a few weeks before Prototype, which has a very similar premise. Zero Punctuation's Ben Croshaw compared the two point by point and finally called it a near-tie, with Infamous slightly ahead.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet