Infamous Second Son gives you great powers and a city with little to do
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for players who want superpowers more than a story
Infamous Second Son is for players who want to feel overpowered in a city they can climb, dash across and tear apart. It's a single-player, third-person action-adventure game for PlayStation 4 from Sucker Punch Productions. It's the third game in the InFamous series and works on its own as a sequel to InFamous 2. You play Delsin Rowe, a Conduit fighting the Department of Unified Protection (D.U.P.) in a fictional version of Seattle.
Critics agreed that it mostly delivers for that player. Players who want a living city, a sharp story or choices with real weight got a much cooler response from reviewers.
Where it delivers: four power sets that each carry the game
Delsin pulls his powers from materials: smoke, neon, video and concrete. Each one works as a weapon and as a way to get around, like using neon to dash up the side of a building. Using powers drains a meter, and you refill it from sources such as smoke rising from exploded cars. You earn the basics of each new set by destroying D.U.P. Core Relays, then upgrade it with Blast Shards scattered around the city.
That loop is where the praise piled up:
- IGN's Vince Ingenito called each power set "strong enough to hang an entire game on" and said the upgrades kept fights fresh.
- Polygon's Phillip Kollar liked neon best but said the balance across all the sets made combat a lot of fun.
- Destructoid's Chris Carter saw the combat's simplicity as its strength and found Delsin easy to control.
- Edge said the enemies were smart enough to keep fights challenging.
A few critics pushed back. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh found the combat imperfect and said the skill upgrades barely changed how it plays. Edge called the parkour in the opening chapter "skittish" and said the game only picks up once the powers arrive and the action moves to Seattle.
The visuals got the most consistent praise. Ingenito said they left him "staring slack-jawed", and GameSpot's Tom Mc Shea called them "incredible". Welsh praised the steady frame rates and long draw distances. One exception: David Meikleham of PlayStation Official Magazine noticed the frame rate dipping during heavy fights.
Where it falls short: a choice system with only two settings
The game tracks whether you play as a hero or a villain. Healing civilians and breaking up drug deals counts as good, and killing innocent people counts as evil. A red-and-blue bird logo on Delsin's jacket shifts to show where you stand. Committing to one side opens up matching powers and a finishing move called the Karma Bomb.
Critics criticized this system more than anything else in the game. Ingenito called it "woefully outdated". He also pointed out that Delsin's powers only reach their peak if you stay fully good or fully evil, so playing anywhere in between gets punished. Mc Shea said it had no "moral gray area". Edge and Welsh said your choices barely touch the story, and Meikleham said they have "little to no impact on gameplay". Joystiq's Danny Cowan was the only critic who defended it, calling the rewards and costs on each side well balanced.
To get the most from the powers, pick a side early and stick with it.
Critics split on the story too. Troy Baker's Delsin won over Carter and Ingenito, but Mc Shea found him annoying and immature, and Meikleham was put off by his arrogance. Ingenito thought supporting characters like Fetch were underdeveloped. Kollar felt the story's look at surveillance didn't go anywhere, and Welsh said the ending felt rushed.
A city you clear, not a city you live in
Outside the story, you take Seattle back one district at a time by tagging graffiti spots and hunting D.U.P. agents. When D.U.P. control of a district drops below 30 percent, you can start a District Showdown to wipe them out there.
Mc Shea called Seattle "a playground" and said the people in it exist mainly as targets. CVG's Tamoor Hussain called the city "hauntingly empty" and said it falls short of the worlds in Grand Theft Auto V, Sleeping Dogs and Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag. Kollar noted that nearly every mission and side activity comes down to beating up more soldiers or thugs. Edge saw little reason to play through twice. Carter was the main exception: he thought there was plenty to do and enjoyed freeing districts and collecting Blast Shards.
Edge's advice is the most useful: treat it as an action game that happens to be set in an open world, not as an open-world game. With that expectation, the side activities feel like extra combat rather than a world that needs filling.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Infamous Second Son en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q6028768 wikidata.org