Island Tour trades Stars for seven short boards that each set their own rules
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One idea: every board writes its own rules
Island Tour drops the Stars and coins that decide most Mario Party games. Instead, each of its seven boards has its own requirements, length and obstacles, and usually its own way to win. Before you pick a board, the game shows how much it depends on skill and on luck, how many minigames it has and roughly how long it takes to play.
That idea is the right test for the rest of the game. Where it holds up, critics were warm. Where luck or short boards undercut it, the complaints pile up.
The boards promise variety, then mostly race to the finish
The variety got the most consistent praise. On Banzai Bill's Mad Mountain, players hide in caves to dodge a Banzai Bill that knocks back anyone in its path. Bowser's Peculiar Peak asks you to finish last. Kamek's Carpet Ride swaps dice for cards. Critics also liked the skill and luck ratings and the estimated play times.
The idea frays from there. A few reviewers noted that, under the different themes, most boards are still a race to the end. Some questioned whether the ratings could be trusted. Caitlin Cooke of Destructoid and Hollander Cooper of GamesRadar+ both missed the old Star and coin system, which no board brings back.
Length is the bigger problem. Nintendo Life's Dave Letcavage pointed out that short boards mean fewer minigames per game. Other critics found the pacing slow because every turn waits on the other players, computer-controlled ones included.
The minigames are the strongest case for buying it
All 81 minigames are new, and all are four-player free-for-alls. A few use the system's microphone, gyroscope or touchscreen, along with augmented reality cards or StreetPass. Critics were mostly enthusiastic:
- Letcavage at Nintendo Life called it "one of the tightest collections" in the series.
- Polygon's Danielle Riendeau called it the game's "greatest asset".
- Digital Spy's Liam Martin put the minigames "among the best" he'd played.
IGN's Scott Thompson disagreed. He found some motion-controlled games awkward and called the lack of two-on-two and three-on-one games "an odd departure for the series". Even so, the modes built around minigames got good notices, especially free play. Time Attack runs a fixed set of 10 minigames against the clock, and Hot-Air Hijinks is a race to win three, five or seven of them.
Luck makes the skill ratings feel like decoration
Critics came down hardest on how much luck decides. The Observer's Andy Robertson said it could make minigames feel inconsequential. Reviewers also called out boards that run on luck rather than skill, and Banzai Bill's Mad Mountain is almost all luck. A board's skill rating doesn't mean much when one roll can undo a lead.
The solo campaign, Bowser's Tower, has its own problem. You climb 30 floors against three computer-controlled copies of your character and face a boss every five floors. Critics enjoyed the boss games, but the computer opponents are easy and you can't raise their difficulty. GameSpot's Heidi Kemps called it "a nice diversion", Letcavage called it "mostly fluff", and Thompson called it "laughably bad".
It works best with a room full of 3DS owners
There's no online multiplayer, and critics criticized that heavily. Local play over Download Play got the opposite reaction. Several people with their own systems can play from a single cartridge, and one review said this is "where this game shines". A few critics did run into occasional connection problems.
Shacknews' Steve Watts questioned the premise itself. He called the 3DS "an odd choice" because a handheld is, in his words, "innately a singular experience". Outside the game, Letcavage found the visuals "satisfactory", Kimberly Keller of Nintendo World Report praised the crisp 3D and the music, and GameRevolution's Kevin Schaller called the collectibles "pointless".
The scores reflect that split:
- Metacritic rates it 58/100.
- On OpenCritic, only 3% of critics recommended it.
- Famitsu's four reviewers gave it 32 out of 40.
The critic average, computed from those critic scores, is 5.8 out of 10.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario Party: Island Tour en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q13063856 wikidata.org