Analysis · Gears of War: Judgment

Judgment's scored missions split critics between a 9.2 and a 3 out of 5

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

IGN called it amazing and Giant Bomb called it thin

The gap between the highest and lowest named scores is wide. IGN gave Judgment a 9.2 out of 10, calling it "amazing" and "a fantastic prequel with super combat." Giant Bomb gave it 3 out of 5. Its review said the campaign twists the Gears formula in some interesting ways but the rest felt "pretty thin" for a full-priced retail product.

Most critics landed between those two. GameSpot scored it 7.5 out of 10, and the Metacritic average sits at 79/100. The critic average of 7.7, computed from critic aggregates, reflects that middle.

The two sides mostly weren't arguing about how the game plays. Few critics faulted the combat. They differed on value: whether a sharp but restructured campaign and a slimmed-down multiplayer suite add up to a complete game. That question decides who should buy it.

The campaign trades sprawl for scorecards

Judgment is a prequel to the first Gears of War. It follows Damon Baird, Augustus Cole and their squad, Kilo, as they stand trial for disobeying orders six weeks after Emergence Day. The over-the-shoulder camera and cover system are unchanged from earlier games.

The structure is what's new. Earlier Gears games used large, open environments. Judgment splits its six chapters into self-contained missions, and you can never go back to an earlier mission's setting. Each mission is graded on:

  • kills
  • head shots
  • gibs

A mission earns up to three stars. Each one also offers an optional harder setting with a condition such as a time limit or a limited set of weapons. Accepting it raises your score.

Collecting 40 stars opens Aftermath, a separate one-chapter campaign that follows on from the Gears of War 3 campaign. It has no stars and no harder setting. That design rewards players who replay missions to improve their grades. Giant Bomb's "interesting" twist to the formula is this structure, and it's also why some critics found the package slight. Short missions built for replay read as generous to score-chasers and as thin to anyone who plays a campaign once.

Multiplayer is where fans pushed back

Critics split over value, but fans objected to the multiplayer changes. Judgment added two modes, OverRun and Free-for-All. It shipped with eight maps: four exclusive to OverRun and four exclusive to COG versus COG, which pits a blue team against a red team.

Several series staples were removed:

  • planting grenades on walls
  • damage boosts from active reloads
  • carrying both a shotgun and a rifle into a fight

The loadout change was later reversed for every standard versus mode except Free-for-All after fans complained. Execution mode came back as free downloadable content two weeks after launch, along with two free maps.

The Locust stayed out of every mode except OverRun, and fans reacted very negatively to that change. If you came to Gears multiplayer to fight the Locust in every mode, Judgment offers that in OverRun alone.

Who the split favors

The disagreement works as a buying guide. If you like mission grades, optional challenge conditions and replaying levels for a third star, IGN's view probably fits you better. Judgment's campaign is built around those things, and critics on both sides credited the combat.

If you want the sweeping set pieces of the main trilogy, or a versus mode with the series' usual rules and factions, Giant Bomb's complaint will probably apply to you. Much of what made earlier Gears multiplayer distinctive was pared back here, and some of it came back only after fan pressure.

Judgment rewards players who replay missions for better grades. Players who finish a campaign once and move on may find it short on content.

Sales showed the same divide. Cowen and Company put first-month US sales at about 425,000 units, roughly a fifth of the two million Gears of War 3 sold in September 2011. By August 2013 it had sold just over one million copies. Fewer players followed the series into Judgment, which makes it easier to judge on its own terms: a well-regarded spin-off campaign with a thinner multiplayer offering.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet