Analysis · Killzone 3

Killzone 3 earned two perfect scores and a charge of backward steps

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Two perfect scores and one 7 for the same game

Destructoid gave Killzone 3 a perfect 10, the highest score among the reviews. Reviewer James Stephanie Sterling praised its "polish, refinement" and called it one of the most complete packages the PlayStation 3 had seen. PlayStation Lifestyle also gave it 10/10 and called it "the ultimate ending" to a sci-fi epic.

GamesTM gave the lowest score, 7/10. It compared the game with Killzone 2 and said the sequel "takes inexplicable backward steps" in nearly every area. The storyline was its main complaint.

Across 23 critic reviews the average came to 83/100, and the critic average, which is worked out from critic scores, is 8.3. The gap between the top and bottom scores comes mostly from what each critic cared about. Presentation and multiplayer pushed scores up. Story and voice work pulled them down.

The look and the 3D carried the praise

PlayStation Official Magazine – UK published the first English review and gave the game 9/10. It called the 3D a "watershed moment". It also said Black Ops was the only PlayStation 3 shooter that could match it. IGN gave it 8.5 and singled out the atmosphere, graphics and multiplayer.

The game had new features to show off. It was the first in the series to support stereoscopic 3D and the first to offer motion controls with the PlayStation Move. Game Informer called the Move support intuitive and noted that it's optional.

Killzone 2 was set mostly in city streets. Killzone 3 covers a wider range of places:

  • frozen Arctic stretches and a deadly alien jungle;
  • nuclear wastelands;
  • battles in space.

New tools change how fights play out. Jet packs return from Killzone: Liberation. A reworked melee system called Brutal Melee lets you chain attacks into combos. The WASP launcher fires rockets in a spiral. The core shooting still closely resembles Killzone 2, so most of the changes are to where you fight and what you carry.

Story and voices are where critics split

The campaign drew the sharpest disagreement. GamesTM faulted the storyline. Game Informer, which gave the game 9/10, liked it. It called the "shocking and abrupt" ending a fitting close to Guerrilla's war trilogy and added that the game stands on its own.

Even critics who liked the game complained about the voice acting. PlayStation Official Magazine – UK said it lacked "emotive punch" and named it as the reason the game didn't get a 10.

Taken together, the reviews describe a shooter you play for its spectacle and its fights. Some critics enjoyed the story and others didn't, so treat it as a bonus.

If a strong plot is what keeps you playing a shooter to the end, go by the GamesTM review. If you mostly want big set pieces, the higher scores are the better guide.

Multiplayer built around fighting over ground

Online play has three modes:

  • Guerilla Warfare: team deathmatch for up to 16 players.
  • Warzone: up to 24 players, with seven objective rounds and the match decided best of seven.
  • Operations: up to 16 players, with the ISA attacking and the Helghast defending. Cutscenes show the best players' moments.

Warzone has the most to offer on paper. Objectives such as Body Count, Capture and Hold and Search and Destroy rotate at random without stopping the match. Tactical Spawn Areas replace Killzone 2's spawn grenades, so teams fight over spawn points, and some spawn points help more with certain objectives than with others. That rewards a team that plans ahead for the next objective.

Offline, two players on one console can play the campaign together in split-screen co-op, which Killzone 2 didn't offer. BotZone lets you play multiplayer matches against computer-controlled bots. Neither mode needs other people online.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet