Analysis · Kinect Star Wars

Kinect Star Wars is at its best when it stops trying to be a Jedi epic

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for a living room full of Star Wars fans

This is a game for people who own an Xbox 360 with the Kinect camera and want to act out Star Wars with their whole body. That might mean a family, a group of friends or a younger fan, and the Teen rating suggests it was pitched at that crowd. There's no controller. You swing your arms to use a lightsaber, gesture to throw objects with the Force, lean to steer, and dance.

Terminal Reality split it into four modes:

  • Jedi Destiny: Dark Side Rising, a campaign where you play a Jedi Padawan, set between The Phantom Menace and Revenge of the Sith.
  • Podracing, with several courses.
  • Rancor Rampage, where you play a rancor and wreck Star Wars locations.
  • Galactic Dance-off, a dance game where you follow famous characters on screen.

There's also Duels of Fate, a one-on-one mode where you face campaign characters and villains such as Darth Vader.

The side modes are where it pays off

The modes that don't take Star Wars seriously drew the warmest reviews. Jonathan Deesing of G4 gave high marks to both Rancor Rampage and Galactic Dance-off. Mark Walton of GameSpot called the dancing "silly" and "comical fun". The joke is the soundtrack: pop songs rewritten with Star Wars lyrics, so "Hollaback Girl" turns into "Hologram Girl" and "Y.M.C.A." turns into "Empire Today". Every stage has a scene to match. Leia dances in front of Jabba the Hutt, and Han Solo dances in the carbon-freezing chamber on Bespin to a rewrite of Jason Derulo's "Ridin' Solo", a routine that reviewers singled out as absurd.

Podracing gets a clever control idea. Your arms are the two engine throttles: stretch both out for full speed, pull one back to ease off an engine. Rancor Rampage maps your arm movements onto the monster and adds special attacks, so you're mostly smashing things, and the motion controls don't have to be precise for that to work.

The less a mode asks for precision, the better critics liked it.

The Jedi campaign is the weak spot

Jedi Destiny is the main event and the mode Star Wars fans would buy the game for. It drew the harshest criticism. Justin McElroy of Polygon pointed to imprecise blocking, a combat formula that repeats and very little room for strategy. Walton at GameSpot found the lightsaber duels slow, and the story too close to the original trilogy. Anthony Gallegos of IGN said the package adds up to a set of minigames, not the "Jedi epic" fans were hoping for.

Even the friendlier reviews admitted the controls slip. Liam Martin of Digital Spy liked the R2-D2 and C-3PO narration and saw real effort from the developer, but said some controls didn't respond at times, which could frustrate players. Lorenzo Veloria of GamesRadar disagreed: you rarely have to repeat a kick or a slash to make it register, and in Veloria's view this is one of the best uses of Kinect in an action game. So critics are split on whether the camera reads you well. They mostly agree the swordplay doesn't feel like being a Jedi.

Effortful, popular and still rough

The reviews pull hard in two directions. Brad Shoemaker of Giant Bomb called it a "shoddy product" no matter who it's aimed at. Martin argued that writing it off as a minigame collection undersells it. Deesing added two practical warnings. Some modes get tiring, and sitting in a chair made podracing less exhausting and more immersive. Deesing also said the graphics look like a Wii game.

The game still sold. It debuted at number one on the UK All Formats Chart, the first Kinect-exclusive game to do that in the UK and the first Star Wars game to top the charts since 2008. It has also turned up on several lists of the worst Star Wars games ever made. Both can be true: the Star Wars name brought people in, and the main campaign let many of them down.

If you're deciding now, judge it by the modes you'd actually play with other people. A group that laughs at the idea of Han Solo dancing in carbonite will get its money's worth. Someone after a solo lightsaber story will not.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet