Kingdom Hearts II trades challenge for some of the PS2's best combat
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A combat system critics adored, in a game they found too easy
Game Informer's Andrew Reiner called the combo potential "divine" and said it beat God of War for intensity. The sharpest criticism came from IGN's Jeff Haynes, who called the partner AI "absolutely terrible" and said the fights had lost their bite. Basic attacks worked so well that offensive magic barely mattered, and enemies dropped so many health orbs that healing items went unused.
Both points hold up, and most of the other reviews fall on one side or the other. Kingdom Hearts II came out on December 22, 2005 for the PlayStation 2. It plays faster and smoother than the first game, and it asks less of the player at almost every turn.
Drive forms and reaction commands carry the fights
The base is real-time hack and slash. Sora attacks with button presses, and a Final Fantasy style menu in the bottom left handles magic, items, summons and combination attacks. Two computer-controlled partners usually fight alongside him, and the menu lets you shape some of their behavior, such as attacking whatever Sora targets. Critics credited the drive forms, limit breaks and combos with adding depth and variety.
The new piece is the Reaction Command, an enemy-specific move you trigger by pressing triangle at the right moment. Eurogamer's Luke Albiges put the best of these on par with the knife fight in Resident Evil 4, and GameZone's Louis Bedigian called them the first quick time events done right. GameRevolution's Russ Fischer and RPGFan's Patrick Gann noted the catch: they take little skill, which may leave hardcore players cold.
Electronic Gaming Monthly liked the boss fights, and GamesRadar+'s Eric Bratcher enjoyed most of them while calling a few "straight-up lame". GameSpot's Carrie Gouskos found the bosses well designed but said beating them rarely took a different plan from beating regular enemies.
Gouskos argued that the first game's challenge came from backtracking, tedium and confusion. If that wore you down, the easier sequel is the better trade.
Smaller worlds and a thinner RPG layer
The focus on combat costs the role-playing side. Haynes called the RPG elements a "casualty" and the items "practically useless". Experience points and leveling are still there, and side quests give characters bonuses, but the story runs in a straight line from one cutscene to the next.
The worlds shrank too. Albiges praised the locations as consistently high quality and singled out Port Royal, but other critics pointed to smaller, more linear spaces, and Haynes called Halloween Town and Atlantica "shadows of their former selves". Atlantica's change from an action set piece into a string of rhythm minigames drew the harshest words. The Hundred Acre Wood minigames fared better, and Bratcher and Gann were glad the first game's scavenger hunt quests were gone.
Critics disagreed about the camera. Haynes said moving it from the shoulder buttons to the right thumbstick made it far more responsive. GameSpy's Gerald Villoria and Gann saw no improvement, and Villoria still ran into forced, awkward angles. EGM's James Mielke dismissed the new first-person view, warning that not being able to see Sora's Keyblade was disorienting.
The Gummi Ship got better, not great
The first game's ship travel was rebuilt as a mix of rail shooter and "Disney theme park ride". Each route to a new world has to be cleared in a shooting level before you can fly there freely, and finishing routes earns new ships. Critics broadly agreed it was an improvement and compared it to Star Fox, Panzer Dragoon and R-Type.
Improved isn't the same as loved, though. Gouskos and PALGN's Phil Larsen were still unimpressed, although Larsen picked out the battle against a giant pirate ship as a highlight. Villoria thought the shipbuilding screen was much better than before, while Fischer and Gann still found it obtuse and confusing.
Where it still stands out: looks and music
Mielke and Albiges ranked the visuals among the PlayStation 2's best, and the Space Paranoids, Timeless River and Port Royal worlds got special mention. Gann called the facial designs the best he'd seen on the console. Haynes and Villoria liked that both the main cast and the enemies change their look to fit each world.
Most reviewers praised the soundtrack, and Bedigian called it "impeccable, unforgettable". There were dissenters. Villoria felt it fell short of the first game, and Gann objected to the synth quality and the tracks recycled from the original.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Kingdom Hearts II en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q626802 wikidata.org