Analysis · Pathfinder: Kingmaker

Kingmaker rewards patient tabletop fans with a kingdom worth ruling

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who miss Baldur's Gate and know the Pathfinder rules

Pathfinder: Kingmaker is aimed at one kind of player. That player grew up on classic computer RPGs like Baldur's Gate and Neverwinter Nights, knows the Pathfinder tabletop game, and wants a long single-player campaign where the rules matter. Owlcat Games built it on that tabletop system, viewed from an isometric angle. Your party mixes established Pathfinder characters with new ones written for the game.

For that player, it mostly delivers. Critics praised the story and the kingdom management. For anyone else, the same depth is the problem. GameSpot's Daniel Starkey pointed to the "gargantuan knowledge base" you need to play it well.

Ruling a kingdom is the part other RPGs don't do

The hook arrives partway in, when your hero is handed a kingdom. You start with one territory and grow by claiming land and founding settlements. Each settlement can grow from village to town to city. Its buildings add bonuses to kingdom stats, plus extras such as fast travel between settlements.

To run the kingdom, you appoint advisors from the companions and allies you've recruited. They take on projects or handle kingdom events. Some events are problems that need solving, and others are opportunities you can ignore without penalty. Success depends on how hard the event is and how skilled the advisor is, and you can spend Crisis Points to improve the odds.

Critics responded to this layer more than to anything else. Game Debate praised the game for offering "an interesting land to rule", and even GameSpot's more reserved review singled out the kingdom management alongside the story.

The alignment system gives your choices more weight. Your character sits somewhere between Lawful and Chaotic and between Good and Evil, and unlike in Baldur's Gate, that alignment shifts with what you decide. It opens extra options in some situations and shapes how your subjects see your rule.

Where it loses people: uneven difficulty and hidden rules

The common complaint was friction, not a lack of ideas. Reviewers criticized an inconsistent difficulty curve and mechanics that don't explain themselves. Starkey wrote that the game was held back by a "litany of small issues" and by balancing problems.

Combat runs either in real time with pause or turn by turn, which helps if one style isn't for you. Traits restrict which classes you can pick, and your class decides which spells, abilities and equipment a character can use, so the choices you make when creating a character carry real weight. Players new to Pathfinder should expect to read up on the rules.

GameSpot's short version: for players with the patience, the payoff is "well worth the investment".

Play it on PC, not PlayStation 4

The 2018 launch was rough. Bugs, long loading screens and balance problems hurt the early reviews and frustrated early buyers. Patches over the following months fixed many of those issues.

The PlayStation 4 edition is the exception. It still crashes regularly, can delete save files, and has frame rate and graphical problems. In an RPG this long, a deleted save can wipe out a lot of progress. The game is also on Windows, macOS and Linux, and the patched versions there are the ones to pick.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet