Analysis · Kirby and the Rainbow Curse

Kirby and the Rainbow Curse rides on a line you draw, and critics split

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Everything runs through a rainbow you draw

The game is built on one idea it carries over from the 2005 DS game Kirby: Canvas Curse. Kirby is stuck as a ball and you never steer him directly. You draw rainbow lines on the Wii U GamePad touchscreen and he rolls along them. Run him through a loop and he speeds up. Tap him and he spins into an attack. Collect 100 stars and he can Star Dash, growing big enough to smash blocks that otherwise can't be broken.

Famitsu liked how simple the controls are. It said drawing lines to guide a character wasn't new, but that HAL Laboratory made it "more interesting to play," and it praised the game's "surprisingly diverse" set of gimmicks. IGN's Marty Sliva praised the difficulty. When the drawing works, critics agreed, the idea holds up across a whole game.

Bosses are where the stylus lets you down

The same idea also caused the strongest complaints. In a negative review, Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert compared the game unfavorably to its DS predecessor. He found the levels too simple and linear and the collectibles too easy to reach. He also missed being able to steal enemy abilities, which Canvas Curse allowed.

His sharpest complaint goes straight to the core design. He found the controls functional, but said the repeated boss fights were frustrating because the stylus lacks precision. When every move depends on how accurately you draw, imprecise drawing hurts most in the fights that need it most.

The vehicle forms split critics too. Kirby turns into a submarine, a rocket and a tank, and each one changes how a level plays. Sliva praised these sections. Ryckert said they left some levels "even more stripped-down."

Beautiful clay, mostly seen on the smaller screen

Critics agreed on the art. Sliva called it "absolutely gorgeous" and pointed to fingerprints left in the clay and the stop-motion movement of the bosses. Hardcore Gamer's Dermot Creegan called it "astoundingly beautiful." Walgren called it the prettiest game on Wii U so far.

The drawing mechanic comes with a cost here. Because you draw on the GamePad, you spend much of the game looking at its lower-resolution screen instead of the TV. Several critics said this meant they couldn't see the HD visuals at their best. Walgren also wished the clay changed how the game plays, the way fabric did in Kirby's Epic Yarn. As it stands, the clay is a look and not a mechanic.

The game's best feature is on the TV, but its controls keep your eyes on the GamePad.

Friends get the controls the bosses needed

Up to three more players can join with Wii Remotes as Bandana Waddle Dees. They can carry Kirby, attack enemies, and are the only characters who can damage the evil hand that sometimes tries to grab him. Ryckert preferred playing as a Waddle Dee, because traditional controls made platforming and bosses more reliable than what he called "unreliable stylus paths." It's telling that the most dependable way to play skips the game's central idea.

For players who stay with the stylus, there's plenty to do:

  • 28 levels in the main story and 48 in Challenge Mode.
  • Hidden treasure chests in every level, some behind puzzles or timed rooms, that reward you with clay figures and music tracks you can view and listen to.
  • A page of Elline's diary at the end of each level.
  • Amiibo support: the Kirby figure lets you Star Dash at any time, King Dedede adds extra HP, and Meta Knight strengthens the spin attack.

Creegan praised the challenges and collectibles, while Ryckert found them too easy to reach. Players who enjoy collecting everything will find more to do in Challenge Mode than in the story.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet