Kirby's 3DS outing is full of clever 3D tricks and short on challenge
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics loved the levels and doubted the difficulty
Triple Deluxe drew its warmest praise from Hardcore Gamer, which called it "one of the best handheld iterations" of the series. Its sharpest criticism came from IGN's Jose Otero. His 6 out of 10 said the platforming and puzzles "rarely require any thought or skill."
Most critics landed nearer the praise. The game averages 80 on Metacritic across 68 reviews, Famitsu's four critics gave it 35 out of 40, and GameSpot gave it an 8 out of 10. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.1.
Both camps describe the same game: a creative platformer that almost never threatens you. Fans of the series' gentle pace will barely notice. Players who want a test will notice in the first world.
Depth is the big idea, and it mostly works
The game plays in 2.5D, and its main trick is the space behind Kirby. Some enemy attacks come out of the background, so levels play across two planes instead of one. Polygon praised the level design as innovative, and GameSpot singled out the use of 3D along with the controls and soundtrack. Even IGN, the harshest major review, liked how the game used 3D and called out its boss battles.
The other headline idea is Hypernova Kirby. Eating a rainbow-colored Miracle Fruit lets Kirby inhale extremely large objects, which gives the levels their biggest set pieces.
The looks were less settled. GameSpot praised the graphics, while Polygon called the overall aesthetics "simple" and "drab" next to earlier Kirby games. That's a minority view, but the game's appeal rests more on its ideas than on its art.
More powers than the levels can test
Four new copy abilities join the roster:
- Beetle uses a rhinoceros beetle's horn to impale enemies, slam them or carry them.
- Bell swings twin bells, blocks with them and attacks with sound waves.
- Archer fires arrows and hides behind fake trees and boulders.
- Circus rides a giant rolling ball, juggles flaming bowling pins and throws exploding balloon animals.
At least 20 older abilities return too, including Wheel, which was missing from Kirby's Return to Dream Land.
This is where IGN's complaint bites. Otero admired that the game gives you more powers than ever. He argued it shouldn't come at the cost of any real difficulty. Bandana Waddle Dee also throws Assist Stars that heal Kirby at the press of the Y button, which makes the main story even more forgiving. A big toolkit is fun to use. It's less fun when no level asks you to choose the right tool.
The extras give it lasting appeal
The main game is single player only, but Triple Deluxe packs in two side games. Kirby Fighters is a Super Smash Bros.-style brawler: you customize a Kirby, give it one of ten copy abilities, and fight other Kirbys in stages based on earlier games. Dedede's Drum Dash is a rhythm game where King Dedede bounces on drums to classic Kirby songs while dodging enemies and collecting coins. There are also keychains to find, showing characters from past games.
Finishing the story opens an extra mode with King Dedede as the playable character. Every boss is swapped for a tougher "DX" version with new colors, more power and new attacks. It ends with fights against Shadow Dedede and Dark Meta Knight from the Mirror World. This is the closest the game comes to answering IGN. If the main story feels too easy, the challenge you're looking for is here.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Kirby: Triple Deluxe en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q3197316 wikidata.org