Analysis · Kirby's Extra Epic Yarn

Kirby's Extra Epic Yarn keeps its charm, but the new powers don't fit

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Top marks for the look, doubts about the levels underneath

Kirby's Extra Epic Yarn is the Nintendo 3DS version of Kirby's Epic Yarn, a 2010 Wii platformer developed by Good-Feel and published by Nintendo. The original got some of the warmest reviews in the series. Metacritic lists it as the highest-rated Kirby game, and The Escapist gave it five stars and said there was "no downside to this game." When the 3DS version came out on March 7, 2019, critics praised it for keeping the original's look and charm.

The sharpest criticism goes in two directions. Edge said the original's levels don't feel as fresh as they look:

"a platform made of butterfly stitching is still just a platform"

The 3DS release adds a new problem of its own. Critics said its copy abilities were introduced inelegantly, dropped into levels that were never designed for them. Which of these matters more to you decides whether this version is worth your time.

A world you pull apart thread by thread

Kirby has been turned into yarn, so he can't inhale enemies or fly the way he does in most Kirby games. Instead he changes shape. In midair he becomes a small parachute to fall slowly, or a weight that smashes down onto enemies. On the ground he turns into a car for speed, and underwater he becomes a submarine. Some areas give him bigger transformations, including a tank that fires missiles, a fire truck and a steam train.

His main attack is a yarn whip. It grabs enemies, winds them into balls of yarn and throws them. The same whip pulls zips, works pulleys and swings from buttons. The art style isn't only decoration. Kirby can tug stray threads and spin balls of yarn to reveal hidden areas or change the shape of the ground. Famitsu called the way the game uses its yarn world "brilliant" and said familiar obstacles felt fresh again.

In the Wii original, the train rode on tracks drawn with the Wii Remote's pointer, and a second player could join as Prince Fluff. The published reviews of the 3DS version don't say how either of those carried over.

You can't lose, and that split critics

Kirby has no health and no extra lives, and he can't die. Taking damage or falling into a pit costs him some of the beads he has collected. At the end of each level you get a wood, bronze, silver or gold medal depending on how many beads you kept.

For some critics, that was the weak spot. GameSpot said the original's "story levels are way too easy," and GameTrailers criticized the fact that you can't die. Others argued the challenge is there if you go looking for it:

  • Game Informer said the game is easy for newer players but still has challenges for experienced ones.
  • Famitsu said collecting every item will test even veteran action players.
  • A gold medal on a boss level earns a hidden patch, which opens extra levels at the end of a world.

There's also a side game. You spend beads on furniture and wallpaper for Kirby's apartment, and decorating other apartments brings in tenants who offer bonus challenges such as time trials.

Soothing music, a narrator people argued about

For the original, critics called the soundtrack tranquil, soothing and jazzy, and they liked the remixes of classic Kirby themes. Not everyone agreed. GameTrailers and Jeremy Peeples of Hardcore Gamer found some tracks too slow and "sleepy." GamesTM said the music rarely matches the Galaxy games but picked out the Melody Town level as the highlight.

Reactions to the storybook narrator were mixed. Peeples called it "a clever approach." Corbie Dillard of Nintendo Life said it fit the light tone but "tends to overdo it a bit." Destructoid's James Stephanie Sterling compared it to a "creepy uncle."

Where the 3DS version lands

The 3DS release scored 79 on Metacritic, based on 48 reviews. A second aggregate of the same reviews put it at 71%. That's lower than the original's reception, and the reasons are specific: the look and charm survived, but the new copy abilities don't fit the old level designs. It also came out near the end of the handheld's life.

The Daily Telegraph's take on the original still describes the audience best: players who want to enjoy the visuals and the cute characters will find it a "breezy and attractive" way to spend around six hours. The Guardian was blunter, saying it works best judged as a platform game for kids.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet