Kirby's first full 3D outing trades free movement for packed, clever levels
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The split was over how Kirby moves, not what he does
Critics agreed on most of Kirby and the Forgotten Land. Their biggest disagreement was over Kirby himself. The few complaints in the reviews centered on movement that felt limited and, in one word reviewers used, "sluggish". Some also found the environments too grounded, and a few were tired of meeting the same mini-bosses again and again.
That is a narrow complaint, but it tells you a lot. This is HAL Laboratory's first mainline Kirby game in full 3D, and the team built the stages around what Kirby can swallow and copy rather than around speed or acrobatics. If you judge a 3D platformer by how good it feels to run and jump through open space, those critics were describing your problem. If you care more about what's hidden in each stage, the same reviews say almost nothing bad.
What critics praised was the stuff inside the levels
The praise focused on level design built around exploration. Reviewers pointed to optional challenges, collectibles and the Treasure Road side levels as the reason each stage felt substantial. The goal in every stage is to free caged Waddle Dees, some found by searching and others won by completing goals set for that stage, so there is always a reason to poke into corners.
Two systems carry the variety:
- Copy abilities that grow. Kirby still inhales enemies to take their powers, and this game adds Drill and Ranger. At Waddle Dee's Weapons Shop, Rare Stones from Treasure Road upgrade those abilities with more attacks. After the credits, Rare Stones can raise an ability's damage further.
- Mouthful Mode. Kirby swallows big objects such as cars and vending machines and takes control of them. Critics praised it for adding variety without feeling bolted on. Car-Mouth Kirby, nicknamed "Carby" by fans, became a favorite well beyond the game.
Boss fights drew credit for making you use your copy abilities, and several critics said Forgotten Land is harder than earlier entries. For a series known for being easy, that matters.
Who that disagreement points toward
Put the praise and the complaints side by side and the audience is clear.
It suits players who like to search. If finding every caged Waddle Dee, clearing Treasure Road and watching the hub fill up sounds good, the reviews describe a game built for you. As more Waddle Dees are rescued, Waddle Dee Town grows and adds minigames: fishing, a part-time job at Waddle Dee Café and a tilting puzzle game. Critics called the town a rewarding reason to keep exploring.
It suits families. A second player can join as Bandana Waddle Dee, fighting with a spear. Critics praised the local co-op as fun and easy to drop into, and noted it works for younger players. It won Best Family Game at The Game Awards 2022, and it is rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7.
It fits less well if you want speed. If you want a 3D platformer where moving through the world is the main pleasure, the "sluggish" complaint is the one to weigh. Nothing in the reception suggests the stages were built for speed or tricky jumps.
How high critics placed it
Critic aggregates sit at 85/100 across 148 reviews, 86/100 across 29 reviews of the Switch version, and 95% positive across 150 reviews. Critics called it one of the best Kirby games ever made. Looking back, Heather Wald of GamesRadar+ put it first in that outlet's ranking of the 10 best Kirby games. It also took an Excellence Award at the Japan Game Awards 2022 and was nominated for Nintendo Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards.
The weak spots critics found were about steering Kirby. Nobody complained that the levels lacked ideas.
The game runs on Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch 2. If you already enjoy Kirby's copy abilities, this version gives them the most room and the most upgrades.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Kirby and the Forgotten Land en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q108670544 wikidata.org