Analysis · Knack 2

Knack II is a couch co-op brawler that critics called better, not great

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for two players and one couch

Knack II is a beat 'em up platformer for the PlayStation 4, and it's clearest about its audience when a second controller comes out. A second player can join the main story and leave again whenever they like, all offline. That one feature shapes who the game suits: a parent playing with a child, siblings of different ages, or a pair who want something light to share on a weeknight.

The Everyone 10+ rating fits that picture. Critics singled out the couch co-op and how easy it is for people of different ages to play together. If that's the evening you have in mind, this is where Knack II is at its strongest.

What the game asks you to do

You control Knack, a character who can punch, kick, change size and block incoming projectiles with a shield. The levels mix fighting with platforming and puzzles that use Knack's abilities and the world around him to open the way forward.

Progress comes in a few layers:

  • Relic Energy collected in levels feeds a skill tree that upgrades Knack's moves.
  • Treasure chests give out Relics or Crystal Parts for further upgrades.
  • Story abilities called Iron, Ice and Stealth change how Knack looks and what he can do.
  • Teleporter pads let you jump between points within a level.

Cutscenes also use quick-time events, where you press a button on cue. The story follows Knack and his companions as they look into a threat from the High-Goblins and their Ancient Weapons.

Where critics saw a step up

The most consistent point in the reviews is a comparison: critics largely treated Knack II as an improvement over the first Knack. Before release, Sony pitched it on its art direction, its co-op and a sharper focus on platforming, and the added skill tree and two-player mode give it more to do than a straight run through levels.

The numbers line up with "better, but not a breakout." One aggregate of 83 reviews put it at 72/100, and another of 17 reviews at 69/100. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, comes to 7.1 out of 10. That's a respectable middle result for a family action game, not a must-own.

Where it falls short

Metacritic's summary label for the game was "mixed or average," and that's the ceiling to expect. Being an improvement on a weak predecessor isn't the same as standing out, and solo players don't get the co-op that most of the praise centers on.

The audience also didn't show up in Japan. The game missed the top sales charts there and debuted at 2,106 units, according to Dengeki. The first game had sold far more largely because it came bundled with every early PS4 in that country.

Its loudest fan is a joke. YouTuber videogamedunkey calls it a "masterpiece" and gave it 10/5, praising Ice Knack and the graphics, but that's satire. Treat it as a meme, not a recommendation.

Who should pick it up

Buy it if you want a gentle co-op action game for a mixed-age household and you can find it at a low price. The drop-in, drop-out design means a younger player can take part for a few minutes without holding things up. Players who mostly play alone and want a polished platformer won't find much here that critics thought rose above average.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet