Knack's clever size-shifting hero is let down by thin combat and hard stretches
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics couldn't agree on what Knack was for
The widest gap in Knack's reviews isn't about any single level. It's about what the game was meant to be. Metro's David Jenkins gave it 3 out of 10 and asked why a "joyless throwback" was a key PlayStation 4 launch title. 411Mania's Gavin Napier gave it 8 out of 10 and also called it a throwback, but he meant it kindly: easy to get into and right for families. Both critics called it a throwback and reached opposite verdicts.
That split runs through the rest of the reviews. Critics who judged Knack as a reason to buy new hardware mostly came away let down. The Guardian's Steve Boxer said it wasn't a bad game but called it "hugely disappointing" for a game meant to sell the console. Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell said it lacked the originality of the older games it echoes. Critics who judged it as a family game were warmer. Game Informer's Matt Helgeson praised its "charm and heart." GameZone's Lance Liebl said its multiplayer made it the best family game on the console at the time.
Sony's Shuhei Yoshida seemed to see the same divide. He had hoped for scores in the mid-70s. He also said Knack showed the console wasn't aimed only at hardcore players. Critic aggregates came in between 56 and 62 out of 100. The critic average, which is computed from those aggregates, is 5.9.
A big idea about size that stays small
Knack is a living creature built from Relics, small ancient pieces that gather around a large central Relic. With more Relics he grows from the size of a child to the size of a gorilla to the size of a small skyscraper. Small Knack jumps higher and moves faster but breaks after a few hits. Big Knack walks over enemies and can throw cars. He can also take on ice, metal or wood, and he can spend energy from Sunstones on tornado attacks, shockwaves and projectiles.
Critics liked that premise. Few thought the game built much on it. IGN's Steve Butts said the shifting size "never really grows" into anything substantial. Most of the play is punching, jumping and dodging through long, linear levels, and the player has no control over the camera. VentureBeat's McKinley Noble called it a solid adventure but criticized its limited combat and linear design.
The look caused less argument. GameSpot's Tom McShea praised the environments, and Destructoid's Dale North called the game "a joy to look at." The levels move through mineshafts, forests, factories, castles and caves in bright greens, oranges and blues. Anime News Network's Dave Riley was harsher. He argued that a lot of care went into animating the pieces and too little went into everything else.
The family pitch runs into the difficulty
This is the problem that matters most for the players the game was trying to reach. Several critics found Knack hard. McShea called the difficulty "surprisingly high." The Escapist's Paul Goodman said it was frustrating at times. The Globe and Mail's Peter Nowak called it a little long and "rather hard." Bramwell also criticized how the checkpoints were spaced.
That works against the case for Knack as a family game. A game that's easy to pick up can still wear down a young player. The fix critics pointed to was the drop-in, drop-out co-op. North suggested playing in short sessions or bringing in a second player when things get tough. Liebl saw the game as a way to introduce kids to a simple brawler-platformer.
Play it in short sessions, or with a partner on the second controller. Critics who liked it kept giving that advice.
Who should pick it up
The record points to a narrow but real audience: a parent and child sharing a PlayStation 4, or a player who wants a simple brawler-platformer and doesn't need anything new. Boxer noted it's one of the longer games of its kind. Digital Spy's Scott Nichols found it more fun the second time through.
Players who want depth or a strong story should look elsewhere. McShea and Butts both faulted the story. Liebl complained that cutscenes interrupt play too often just to show Knack jumping. The game is rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 12.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Knack (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q5102494 wikidata.org