Analysis · Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

Knights of the Old Republic still rewards players who'd rather talk than swing

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want their choices to stick

This game is for the player who reads every dialogue option before picking one. It's a single-player role-playing game set in the Star Wars universe, and BioWare built it on Dungeons & Dragons rules, specifically the d20 System. If your favorite part of a role-playing game is deciding who your character becomes, you're the target.

You start by picking one of three classes: Scout, Soldier or Scoundrel. Later you choose a Jedi path: Guardian, Sentinel or Consular. Every level brings skill points to spend, plus tiered feats and Force powers that work much like spells in a fantasy game.

The story is the reason critics kept handing it awards

For story-first players, it delivers in a big way. The Academy of Interactive Arts and Sciences gave it "Outstanding Achievement in Character or Story Development," and Computer Games Magazine gave it an award for "Best Writing." In 2007, Game Informer ranked its plot twist second on a list of the top 10 video game plot twists of all time.

Much of that comes from the light side and dark side system. It tracks everything from small word choices to major plot decisions. Kind, generous choices pull you toward the light. Selfish or violent ones push you toward the dark, which changes how your character looks (yellow eyes, pale skin) and which dialogue options open up. Your choices show up on your character's face.

Companions do a lot of the work too. Two can travel with you at a time. They join conversations with other characters, start arguments with each other and sometimes hand you new quests. One of them, HK-47, won "Original Game Character of the Year" at the 2004 Game Developers Choice Awards.

Computer Games Magazine's editors called its "elegance and accessibility" a model for the whole genre.

Combat runs on dice, and you can stop the clock

Fights run in rounds. Everyone acts at the same time, but the actions play out one after another on screen, and each combatant gets a limited number of actions per round. You can set the game to pause at certain events or at the end of each round, or never pause at all so it feels closer to real time.

That suits a tactical player well. You can queue orders for your two companions or let them fight on their own. And if you want to know why a lightsaber swing missed, a menu shows the full breakdown, die rolls and modifiers included.

It suits an action player less. Your reflexes don't decide fights; your character's stats and the dice do. Anyone hoping for fast, reflex-driven lightsaber duels should know that going in.

Where it falls short for its own audience

The record holds almost no criticism. It earned "universal acclaim" on Metacritic, and published critic scores range from 8/10 to 95%. The critic average of 8.6 out of 10, drawn from 4 critics, matches that consensus. The weak spots here are judgment calls drawn from how the game is built, not complaints critics made.

  • The side games are a mixed bag. Swoop racing earns money, and pazaak, a card game close to blackjack, lets you gamble. But space travel is sometimes interrupted by a turret-shooting sequence against enemy starfighters, which has little to do with the role-playing around it.
  • A party of three is tight. With only two companions along at once, you'll miss some of the banter from whoever stayed behind.
  • It's a 2003 game. The praise mostly comes from its launch year, and its design reflects that era.

Plenty of ways to play it now

It first came out on Xbox in July 2003 and on Windows on November 19, 2003. Aspyr later ported it to Mac OS X, iOS and Android, and a Nintendo Switch version arrived on November 11, 2021. It also runs on Xbox 360, Xbox One and Xbox Series X and Series S through backward compatibility. It's rated Teen and PEGI 12, so it's fine for most younger teens.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet