Analysis · The Last of Us: Left Behind

Left Behind finds its best moments in a water gun fight, not a firefight

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Half the game is play in the literal sense

Left Behind gives you two kinds of play, and they alternate. In one, Ellie sneaks, shoots and fights hand to hand through a mall in Colorado, looking for medical supplies to save a wounded Joel. In the other, set three weeks before the events of The Last of Us, she wanders an abandoned mall in Boston with her best friend Riley, and almost nobody is trying to kill her.

That second half is what makes the expansion stand out. The Boston mall is full of things to use: a carousel, a photo booth, a video arcade, a mask store and a stall of water guns. Each one does something. The photo booth lets you pick poses for a picture. Picking up a water gun starts a fight with Riley. None of it is filler. These scenes are how the game builds the friendship that the rest of the story depends on.

Eurogamer's Stace Harman praised how closely the playing is tied to the story, saying it adds "diversity and dynamism." That's the expansion's main achievement: the moments where you're just goofing around count as much as the fights.

One new trick that changes the fights

The Colorado sections play like the main game: third-person view, gunfights, melee and a cover system, with Ellie as your only character. The one real addition is that you can throw objects to draw the Infected toward human enemies. Get it right and the two groups fight each other, so you have fewer enemies left to deal with yourself.

Critics liked it. Game Informer's Matt Helgeson called these three-way fights "engaging," and The Daily Telegraph's Tim Martin pointed out that Ellie's body size lets her move "quieter and faster" through the environments. The result is combat that rewards planning a fight more than winning it with bullets.

Where the fighting overstays its welcome

The criticism is aimed at one place. Late in the game, a sequence asks you to kill a large number of enemies, and it doesn't match the restraint of the rest of the expansion. GameSpot's Tom Mc Shea called it "unnatural," and IGN's Colin Moriarty called it "forced."

Electronic Gaming Monthly's Eric L. Patterson gave the clearest warning:

Players who come "more for the gameplay than the story" will feel "disappointed," in Patterson's words.

That's a fair way to set expectations. Left Behind is a character piece with fights in it, not an action game with a story attached.

Ellie and Riley are the reason it's remembered

Reviewers kept coming back to the relationship between Ellie and Riley. Polygon's Philip Kollar said the two girls "aren't easy stereotypes," and Helgeson wrote that Riley is played with the same "emotional depth and subtlety" as the main cast. Harman felt the expansion even improves your understanding of Joel and Ellie.

The kiss between Ellie and Riley got the most attention. Kotaku's Kirk Hamilton called it "a big deal," and IGN's Keza MacDonald said it left her "dumbstruck." Amplify, a project of Advocates for Youth, reported that the scene also drew criticism from some players.

The places themselves were praised as well. Kollar called the locations "beautiful," and Moriarty liked the mall setting because it looks like an ordinary place from the world before the outbreak. Mc Shea noted that the focus on exploring gives the environments room to "breathe."

Not everyone was convinced. Nick Cowen of Computer and Video Games found the story "less satisfying" than the main game's because it adds little new about Ellie, though he still called it "action-packed and enjoyable."

A side story with an awards shelf

Left Behind came out on PlayStation 3 on February 14, 2014, and on PlayStation 4 that July. For 2014, it was GameRankings's highest-rated PlayStation 3 game. GameSpot named it PS3 Game of the Year. At the 11th British Academy Video Games Awards, both its story and Ashley Johnson's performance won awards, and the story was also honored at the 67th Writers Guild of America Awards. The critic average, calculated from nine critics, is 8.7 out of 10.

Polygon's Samit Sarkar summed up why it lasts: it's a "terrific side story" that is "even more impressive" on its own. It's worth playing once the main game is done.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet