Analysis · Lies of P

Lies of P turns Pinocchio's lying into a Soulslike's sharpest idea

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A puppet who can lie, in a genre built on punishment

Lies of P rests on one idea: take Carlo Collodi's 1883 novel The Adventures of Pinocchio and rebuild it as a Soulslike. You control P, a silent puppet, through Krat, a city inspired by the Belle Époque. Automaton Puppets run its industry and daily life, and a petrification disease has disfigured its citizens.

The Pinocchio part is more than costume. At set moments the game gives you a timed choice to tell the truth or lie, and those choices change how the plot develops and which ending you get.

Critics mostly agreed the idea works. The game's critic average is 8.1, computed from critic aggregates that sit between 80 and 82 out of 100. The argument was over how much of the game belongs to that idea and how much is borrowed from FromSoftware, Bloodborne in particular. GameSpot praised its originality but warned it could seem "overly derivative." VG247 went further and called it a "pale imitation."

The story earns the premise, if you reach the third act

The retelling drew the warmest praise. GamesRadar+ called its take on Collodi "thoughtful and confluent," IGN put it among its favorite stories in the genre, Polygon liked how P grows as a character, and PC Gamer singled out the dialogue.

The doubters had specific complaints:

  • Shacknews felt P lacks a clear personality.
  • VideoGamer called the narrative the weakest part, though engaging enough to hold interest.
  • GameSpot found the story vague and disappointing until the third act.
  • VG247 called the lie system "perfunctory," while The A.V. Club liked it.

So the central idea pays off most for players who stay to the end. It's a slow build, not a hook that grabs you in the first hour.

Combat where the weapon is part of the fight

Most weapons are built from a blade and a handle, which you can upgrade and swap with similar parts. A combined weapon gains a special move called a Fable Art. Your other arm takes Legion Arms, tools that include a grappling hook. Parrying staggers an enemy and damages their weapon. Blocking costs a little health, which you win back by hitting back. Weapons also wear down in a fight, and grindstones repair them.

Death has a sharper edge than usual. You drop your Ergo, the currency used for both shopping and leveling, and you can recover it where you fell. But every hit you take on the way back shrinks what's left to recover.

PCGamesN called the balance between these systems "genuinely impressive," Push Square praised the combat and skill tree, and Shacknews enjoyed the weapon combining most. Rock Paper Shotgun said the animations "flow into one another beautifully." Game Informer called the bosses "highly memorable," and most of them fight in two phases.

The pushback was real. VG247 called the combat "wasted potential" and some animations "infuriating," TechRadar found the difficulty inconsistent, and The A.V. Club noted some monotony in the encounters.

Krat looks the part, but walking it split critics

Visuals and sound got the most consistent praise. The visuals earned nominations at the Golden Joystick Awards and The Game Awards, and IGN said the soundtrack "truly stands out" in the genre.

The city's layout is where opinion divided. Gamereactor praised the level design, while Eurogamer called it a "theme park facade" and the game's weakest element. GamesRadar+ felt reused assets across locations hurt immersion, and IGN and Sports Illustrated both reported minor visual glitches.

Krat does reward poking around. Ringing phones pose riddles, and right answers earn Trinity Keys that open rooms full of gear. Hidden Cryptic Vessels lead to more chests.

Overture makes the best part better

The Overture expansion did even better with critics than the base game. IGN rated its bosses as the standout and better balanced than the originals, and TechRadar called some of them among the best in the genre. GameSpot praised its "terrific job of building tension" but called the main villain an "over-the-top cartoon." IGN's main reservation was that it "plays it fairly safe" with new mechanics.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet