Analysis · Code Name: S.T.E.A.M.

Lincoln's steampunk squad fights aliens in a clever but slow 3DS tactics game

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Hard to put down for some critics, a dull debacle for one

Critics landed far apart on this game. At GameTrailers, Ben Moore called it "a complex game that's hard to put down" and praised its range of play styles and character upgrades. At Polygon, Justin McElroy first called it a "misguided, horrifically dull debacle" and admitted he didn't finish it.

Most reviewers came down between those two, and the game's critic aggregates read as "mixed or average". The critic average, worked out from those aggregates, is 6.8 out of 10. That split has a simple cause. Critics who liked the systems liked them a lot, and critics who didn't found the pace hard to sit through.

Steam makes every move a spending decision

The core idea is a shared resource called steam. Moving costs steam and firing costs steam, and the cost depends on the weapon. If you hold back enough steam to fire, some characters can take overwatch shots during the enemy's turn and hit aliens that walk into view, sometimes stunning them for the rest of that turn. The aliens can do the same to you, so pushing ahead carelessly gets punished.

You choose up to four agents for each level from a roster that grows to 12 over the story, and collecting 100,000 medals unlocks a thirteenth, a small mech called Stovepipe. Each agent brings:

  • a primary weapon of their own;
  • a sub-weapon you can swap between characters;
  • a passive ability, such as shoving crates or buffing allies nearby;
  • a special move, once per level, that costs no steam.

This is the part critics praised most. Game Informer's Kimberley Wallace said the game's "biggest assets are its variety and unpredictability". IGN's Jose Otero called the arsenal "wacky, but also extremely deep". GameRevolution's Ryan Bates thought strategy fans would "eat up" the level tactics, and he also thought newcomers would find it easier to get into than other strategy games of the time.

The missing overhead map cuts both ways

The camera stays behind your agents like a third-person shooter's, and there's no overhead view of the map. Otero saw that as a design choice that makes you "have to think carefully" to avoid ambushes. GameSpot's Austin Walker saw the same missing view producing a "slow, dreary march forward" as players crept from cover to cover.

Both readings hold up. A limited view gives overwatch its tension, because you can't see what's waiting for you. But when, as Walker wrote, the levels themselves are "uninspired", careful creeping turns into routine. Expect to play cautiously, because the game rewards it.

The enemy-turn problem, and the update that fixed it

The sharpest complaint was about waiting. Destructoid's Kyle MacGregor found the game "a heady, engrossing experience" but called the enemy turns "hellaciously long". With overwatch and a limited camera, you spend a lot of time watching the aliens move.

Nintendo later released an update that lets players fast-forward through enemy turns. McElroy then revised his Polygon review, writing that it was "a whole lot easier to deal with its faults after the patch" and easier to recommend. A critic going from not finishing the game to recommending it is the clearest sign of how much that downtime weighed on the original release.

The style carries more weight than the story

The setting is an alternate steampunk history drawn in a Silver Age comic book style, with a cast taken from American literature and folklore. The Japanese subtitle, Lincoln vs. Aliens, sums up the premise. GamesRadar's Henry Gilbert praised its "unique world full of memorable characters", and Moore enjoyed its "absurd moments".

The story behind the look got less credit. Walker called it "underdeveloped" and said it gives up on itself "in favor of pure aestheticization". Otero thought the alien enemies were less memorable to look at than your own squad. Come for the cast and the systems, not the plot.

There's more to do once the campaign is over. Cleared chapters return as challenge missions with handicaps, such as hidden steam gauges, in exchange for medal bonuses. Local and online multiplayer offers a timed deathmatch, a medal race over 5 turns and real-time battles between A.B.E. mechs.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet