LittleBigPlanet 3 has a huge toolkit and a buggy, short campaign
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics agreed on the toolkit and split over what breaks
Critics disagreed most about LittleBigPlanet 3's technical state. Joystiq's Justin Clark gave it 4.5/5 and called it "a foundation" that made creation more accessible than ever. IGN's Lucy O'Brien gave it 6.8/10, liked the design and visuals, and still marked it down for "game-breaking" bugs on the PlayStation 4. Eurogamer's Chris Schilling gave it 7/10 and said it was held together by "Sellotape rather than superglue", in constant danger of falling apart.
The aggregates show the same split. Metacritic put it at 79/100 from 76 reviews, but only 64% of critics recommended it on OpenCritic. Most reviewers liked it. Fewer were willing to recommend it outright.
The split has a clear cause. Critics who judged it as a creation suite mostly forgave the rough edges. Critics who judged it as a platformer to play through ran into bugs, and the bugs counted for more.
Three new characters, too little room to use them
Sackboy now shares the game with three new characters, each built around a different way of moving:
- OddSock, a four-legged, dog-like runner who's faster than Sackboy and can wall-jump.
- Swoop, a bird who flies freely and can carry light objects and most other characters.
- Toggle, who switches between Big Toggle, heavy enough to hold down pressure plates, and Little Toggle, small enough to run across water and fit through tight gaps.
Critics praised the new characters more than anything else in the game, and they also complained that the game rarely uses them. Destructoid's Chris Carter called them the "best thing to happen to the series" in years, then said it was a shame they so rarely get to show what they can do. GameSpot's Alexa Ray Corriea liked how the controls change with each character but criticized how little the adventure mode and co-op use them. IGN raised the same complaint about co-op.
The adventure mode is the weak half
The adventure mode got mixed reviews. GameSpot found its levels "challenging but rewarding", and Joystiq praised the way the adventure mode changes pace and scale. GamesRadar's Louise Blain gave the game 8/10 but called the adventure mode "too short", with frustrating checkpoints and pre-built content she found slightly disappointing.
Polygon's Philip Kollar gave it 7/10 and summed up a common feeling: the game has the series' big ideas but never fully commits to them, and plays mostly like a "proof of concept" for a better sequel. Hardcore Gamer's Kevin Dunsmore said much the same at 3.5/5. He found it charming but held back because the developer didn't fully develop its own ideas.
Creation is where it earns its place
Even critics who were tough on the campaign praised the creation tools. The new Power-up Creator lets you build your own power-ups to go with the ones the game includes, such as the Pumpinator, which blows and sucks air to move light objects, and the Blink Ball, which teleports you. There are 70 tools in total, along with improved versions of tools from the earlier games. Popit Puzzles, a separate tutorial mode hosted by Larry Da Vinci and Victoria von Bathysphere, teaches the tools, and GameSpot, Eurogamer and GamesRadar all praised the tutorials.
The game also brings the series' history with it. All downloadable content packs from LittleBigPlanet and LittleBigPlanet 2 carry over on both consoles, and Hardcore Gamer pointed to the millions of community levels imported from earlier games. One catch: story progress from the earlier games doesn't carry over to the PlayStation 4 version.
The D.I.C.E. Awards named it Family Game of the Year, which fits a game built around making and sharing things together.
Who comes out ahead
The split among critics points to two different buyers. If you want to build levels, characters and gadgets, nearly every review backs you up. The toolkit is large, the tutorials are good, and the bugs matter less when you're mostly in the editor.
If you want a platformer to play through, critics were less kind. You get a short adventure mode, new characters it doesn't use enough, and bugs that two major outlets called game-breaking on the PlayStation 4. Families with a young builder in the house sit closest to the builder group. Solo players who just want a campaign should start with LittleBigPlanet 2.
Sources
- Wikipedia: LittleBigPlanet 3 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17194812 wikidata.org