Lollipop Chainsaw sells its jokes harder than its chainsaw combat
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Built for players who want the joke first
Lollipop Chainsaw is for players who pick a game for its voice before its mechanics. It's a 2012 hack-and-slash from Grasshopper Manufacture, made by designer Goichi Suda and filmmaker James Gunn. It stars Juliet Starling, a cheerleader who carves through hordes of zombies while her boyfriend Nick's disembodied head hangs from her waist.
If that premise makes you grin, critics broadly agree you'll get something out of it. If you want a combat system to master, critics were much less kind. The aggregates sit at 65/100 across eight reviews each for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 versions, and 72/100 across 25 reviews. That puts the critic average, computed from those critic numbers, at 6.9 out of 10. It's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18, and the content backs that up.
What it asks you to do between punchlines
The core loop is simple. Juliet mixes melee attacks, dodges, and high and low chainsaw swings. Beat a zombie into a groggy state and one chainsaw hit finishes it. Killing three or more zombies at once or in quick succession triggers Sparkle Hunting, which pays out platinum medals for costumes, music and artwork.
Gold medals come from kills, smashed objects and rescued classmates. You spend them at Chop2Shop.zom stores inside each level on new moves, combos and stat boosts. Later, Juliet gets the Chainsaw Dash for charging and launching off ramps, and the Chainsaw Blaster for long-range shots.
- Lollipops restore health. How many she can carry depends on the difficulty.
- Nick's head can be stuck onto a headless zombie body for rhythm-button sections that clear a path.
- Nick Tickets spin a roulette of head-based attacks, from a bombardment to a mass stun.
- The star meter fills as you kill and powers up the chainsaw for a short stretch.
On paper that's plenty of variety. Critics split on whether it adds up to good fighting.
Where it delivers: the writing, the bosses, the detours
Almost every outlet credited the game's personality. GameSpot praised its jokes, its boss battles and its gameplay excursions. IGN liked its look and feel. The Daily Telegraph called it "an endearing mess" and argued that its quirky edge and "strong writing" carry it through the weaker stretches. Digital Spy called it "silly, short-lived fun" that should stick with players who see it through.
A few critics defended the fighting too. Destructoid called the Xbox 360 combat "intuitive, solid," and its reviewer, James Stephanie Sterling, named it one of their favorite games of 2012. GameZone also praised the combat, and the Japanese magazines Famitsu and Dengeki PlayStation reviewed it positively. Players showed up as well. It became Grasshopper Manufacture's most successful game, with over 1 million units sold by March 2014.
Where it falls short: the combat, the camera, the tone
The case against it is about how it plays. IGN called the gameplay "bland, slow, and unsatisfying." Game Informer said the execution has "too many holes" to embrace fully. Even while praising it, GameSpot flagged quirks in the controls and camera and criticized the combat. GameZone liked the game but noted that the camera gets stuck against walls and takes a few seconds to recover. 411Mania reviewed the PlayStation 3 version and said that, judged on combat alone, it would be "rather terrible."
Critics nearly all agreed that the premise is better than the play. They split over whether the premise is enough.
The humor isn't safe ground either. The Escapist found it overused, and 1UP.com called the game "empty and image-focused." The Digital Fix went furthest. It said the game slides past parody into an "uncomfortable skin-fest" and, for all its excess, is boring. Even the Telegraph, which liked it, said its satire too often runs into trouble. If a crude, leering tone wears on you, nothing in the mechanics will win you back.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Lollipop Chainsaw en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1868703 wikidata.org