Lords of the Fallen pairs a clever second world with uneven footing
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for soulslike regulars who want a twist
Lords of the Fallen is built for players who already like hard third-person action role-playing games in the Dark Souls mold. It doesn't ease newcomers in. You lose unspent experience, called Vigor, when you die twice. Checkpoints are sparse, and a harder Veteran mode sits beside the standard Legacy Mode at character creation.
For that player, it brings one big new idea and a combat system critics mostly liked. For anyone hoping for a story or characters to care about, the reviews give much less to go on. Critic aggregates sit at 72/100 on PC, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S, and the critic average, computed from those critic numbers, is 7.0.
The lantern and the land of the dead are the standout
The game lays two worlds over the same space. Axiom is the world of the living. A magic lantern lets you look into, and cross into, Umbral, the world of the dead. A path blocked in one can be open in the other, so exploring means switching between them all the time.
Umbral also changes what death means. Die once in Axiom and you drop into Umbral for a second chance. Die there too and you're back at your last Vestige, the game's checkpoints, without your unspent Vigor. You can also craft your own checkpoints from materials dropped by Umbral monsters, a useful fix for the long gaps between Vestiges.
Critics liked this idea. GamesRadar called the two-world system "clever stuff" that works well, and GameStar said the window into the dead alone gives the world a harmonious design. PC Gamer liked it too but felt HexWorks "could've done more with the concept".
Combat hits hardest against human-sized bosses
You can carry a weapon in each hand plus one ranged option, which can be a catalyst for spells, a ranged weapon or throwables. Like Bloodborne's rally mechanic, you can win back lost health by hitting enemies before you take the next hit. Enough hits or a parry staggers a foe and opens a critical strike.
Reviewers rated the fighting as the game's best part. GamesRadar called combat probably its greatest strength and said blows feel good to land. PC Gamer called the magic system "a genuine improvement" over other soulslikes and said the combat "shines" against humanoid bosses.
PC Gamer found the boss fights fair but the regular fights between them too difficult.
That split matters. If you enjoy grinding through hard rooms, the uneven difficulty is part of the appeal. If you only enjoy the boss duels, the stretches between them are where the game will lose you.
Where it falls short
- Characters and setting. GamesRadar couldn't find "any relatable characters" and called the world's look a mix of Blasphemous and black-mana cards from Magic: The Gathering.
- Performance. Reports differ. GamesRadar had to lower the graphics a lot on a strong desktop PC, while PC Gamer said the game generally ran smoothly, even when using the lamp.
- Ambition. GamesRadar's summary was that the game's goal of being "Dark Souls 4" may have been a reach.
Metacritic shows the split by platform: the PC version rated "generally favorable", the PS5 version "mixed or average". In Japan, four Famitsu critics gave it 32 out of 40.
Co-op makes the hard parts easier to share
You can play the whole campaign with a second player. At a Vestige you can call in a helper for tough enemies or bosses. If both players have beaten a similar number of bosses, shared co-op lets both keep the same world state, progress, items and Vigor. Invasions add player-versus-player fights for anyone who wants that pressure. Players who found the regular fights too punishing can lean on co-op to get through them.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Lords of the Fallen (2023 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q106906209 wikidata.org