Analysis · Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel

Low gravity and ice guns freshen Borderlands, but missions rarely use them

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every fight now happens partly in the air

The new moves change combat right away. On the low-gravity moon, you jump higher but fall more slowly, and loot and dead enemies float off into the sky. An O2 kit supplies your air in space and also works as a jetpack. You can double jump, hover over a fight and come down in a ground slam. Different kits add different stat bonuses and change how much damage a slam does.

New cryogenic weapons slow enemies and then freeze them solid. A frozen enemy takes extra damage from explosives, melee hits and critical shots, and shatters when it dies. That gives every encounter a simple rhythm: freeze an enemy, then pick the hit that finishes it. Laser guns join the usual loot pool as a second new weapon type.

Critics responded most to this part. Vince Ingenito at IGN said the gear options and low gravity made the game 'a fresh experience'. Evan Lahti at PCGamer said the new features gave Borderlands combat novelty and a new gracefulness. Darren Nakamura at Destructoid, one of the harsher reviewers, still praised the combat as fast and tactical.

The missions rarely ask for the new moves

The most common complaint was about mission design, and it undercuts the game's main strength. Lahti said the missions seldom made use of the mechanics the game had just introduced. Jessica Conditt at Joystiq found the missions predictable and short on variety. She also criticized confusing level design and frustrating deaths. The Escapist criticized the map design and frustrating enemy encounters.

Ingenito liked the story, which centers on Jack, but criticized its poor pacing. His later review of the Claptastic Voyage add-on makes the gap clear. IGN scored that campaign 8.4 out of 10 because it used the anti-gravity mechanics better and avoided the main game's 'excessive backtracking'. The tools work fine. The main campaign just doesn't ask much of them.

Funny writing, thin plot, mixed polish

The writing pleased most critics. David Roberts at GamesRadar praised the hilarious script and the varied character classes. Conditt singled out the comedic bosses and well-defined classes, and Daniel Bloodworth at GameTrailers said the new playable characters were worth exploring.

The story itself got less credit. Roberts called it weak, and Nakamura was disappointed by the ending. Nakamura also reported a number of bugs and found the environmental art boring, though Conditt praised the environments as unique. Adam Beck at Hardcore Gamer was the harshest critic quoted. He gave it 2.5 out of 5, criticized the bugs, loot, script and world design, and called it 'unpolished' and 'uninspired'. Even he allowed that it can be fun with friends.

Plenty to grind, little that's new

There's a lot to keep you playing:

  • The Grinder takes combinations of your existing weapons and returns one of higher rarity. The Escapist praised the way it lets you combine weapons.
  • New vehicles, including a Moon buggy and the Stingray hoverbike.
  • True Vault Hunter Mode, a harder second playthrough unlocked when you finish the campaign.
  • Ultimate Vault Hunter Mode, a third playthrough unlocked when you beat the second and reach level 50.
  • Co-op and multiplayer, which several critics treated as the best way to play.

The longer it runs, the more familiar it feels. Roberts called it 'a fun diversion' rather than a meaningful new chapter. Lahti said it doesn't deviate much from the feel and format of Borderlands 2. The Escapist also found it too similar to earlier entries.

The scores reflect that. Metacritic gave the PlayStation 3 version 77, Windows 75 and Xbox 360 74. Other critic aggregates sit at 72 to 74 out of 100, and the critic average calculated from them is 7.3. The game was developed by 2K Australia with Gearbox Software and is rated PEGI 18. Updated ports for Windows, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One came later as part of Borderlands: The Handsome Collection.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet