Analysis · Madden NFL 17

Madden NFL 17 wins critics over on franchise mode and loses them in the booth

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The split is between how it plays and how it sounds

Critics barely disagreed about the score. Metacritic lists 82/100 for each of the four console versions (PlayStation 4, PlayStation 3, Xbox One and Xbox 360), each based on nine reviews. A second aggregate, drawn from 59 reviews, landed at 83/100, and another tally of 60 reviews came to 82%. The critic average, computed from those critic numbers, is 8.3 out of 10.

The real friction shows up inside the reviews. IGN gave the game an 8.6/10, praising the franchise mode and the defense, but said it was disappointed by the commentary. GamesRadar gave it 4/5 and focused on changes to core mechanics and the overhaul of franchise mode. So critics agreed about what happens on the field and in the front office. Their doubts were about what you hear while it happens.

That tells you who will like it. If you mute the commentary or barely notice it, the main complaint mostly goes away. If the play-by-play voices are a big part of the appeal for you, expect some letdown.

Franchise mode is the reason to own this one

Both outlets named franchise mode, and GamesRadar called it the series' "marquee" mode. That outlet also tied its praise to the usual knock on yearly sports games: that each new entry phones it in and makes little progress. GamesRadar's verdict was that Madden NFL 17 avoided that charge, and it credited both the mechanical changes and the franchise overhaul.

For the reader, this is the simplest test:

  • You play seasons, not single games. Franchise mode is where critics saw the biggest step forward, so this is the entry to pick.
  • You mostly play quick head-to-head matches. The franchise work matters less to you, and the critics' praise for defense becomes the main draw.

Defense drew praise, but the details are thin

IGN singled out the defense as a strength, and GamesRadar described major changes to some of the game's core mechanics. The published reception doesn't say exactly what changed, so take it as a general signal: critics thought the game played differently from the year before, and better.

That counts for something in a series that comes out every year. A player who skipped the previous entry, Madden NFL 16, would find changes critics called significant, not cosmetic ones.

The newer consoles get the real upgrade

Madden NFL 17 was the last Madden released on PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, and the last to use the Ignite engine. The older-console versions are based on Madden NFL 25, an earlier entry. That means the improvements critics praised are best judged on PlayStation 4 or Xbox One rather than on the older base. The aggregate scores are the same across all four versions, but each rests on only nine reviews.

A hit that sold a little less than the year before

The game kept its standing in the industry. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Sports Game of the Year at the 20th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards. The NPD Group reported it as the best-selling retail game in the US in its release month, though its launch-month sales fell short of Madden NFL 16's.

The takeaway: critics rewarded the changes, and the main complaint was the commentary, not the football.

If commentary is what spoils a sports game for you, look elsewhere in the series. If you want a deep season mode and a defense critics enjoyed, this entry holds up.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet