Mafia II plays like a mob film you drive through, for better and worse
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A gangster movie with a controller attached
The idea behind Mafia II is simple. It tells a mob story the way the films do, then puts you in the driver's seat. You play Vito Scaletta, a young Sicilian-American war veteran who comes home to Empire Bay and gets pulled into a power struggle between the city's crime families. He's trying to pay off his father's debts and build a better life, and the job keeps asking more of him.
Game Informer's Matt Bertz bought the pitch completely. He gave the game 9.0/10 and wrote that it draws on mobster film history to tell a drama about family, friendship, loyalty and betrayal. GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd scored it 8.5 and praised its "uncompromising mob story." For those critics, the cinematic approach was the whole point, and it worked.
Empire Bay is a period set first and a playground second
The city covers 1945 to 1951, and the game treats that span like set dressing on a film. It moves from snowy winter chapters, where cars slide on icy roads, into the early 1950s. There are 50 era-accurate vehicles, and three in-game radio stations play news, commercials and licensed music from Chuck Berry, Dean Martin, Muddy Waters, Buddy Holly and others.
Even the cutscenes are built to keep the illusion going. They run in the game engine in real time, so if your car is dented and your coat is wrong when a scene starts, that's what the scene shows. Only the opening and one cutscene in the tenth chapter are pre-rendered video.
That attention to detail serves the film idea well. It also explains the most common complaint. Empire Bay is built to be looked at as you drive to the next scene, not filled with distractions.
Shooting and driving carry the scenes in between
Between the story beats, the game comes down to two things: shooting and driving. Melee combat is limited to punching and dodging. Gunfights lean on a cover system, a clear step up from the first game's crouch, with a period arsenal that includes the Thompson submachine gun, the Colt 1911, a pump-action shotgun, the MG 42 and the Beretta Model 38.
A two-button setup separates a standard action from a "violent" one. When you steal a car, for example, you can pick the lock or smash the window. It's a small touch, but it lets you choose how rough Vito is without stopping the story.
IGN's Greg Miller landed in the middle at 7/10. He called it a solid, fun ride and warned players not to "expect the world." That's a fair read of systems that do their job without going much further.
Where the film idea falls apart
The sharpest attack came from Eurogamer's John Teti, who gave the game 4/10. His argument goes straight at the premise. If the game shows mob life honestly, he wrote, it shows a dull routine of repetitive tasks done by "aggressively stupid automatons." In that reading, the faithful gangster story is exactly what makes the game boring to play.
A mob drama can hold you through a two-hour film. Stretched across a game, the errands between the big scenes start to show.
The Definitive Edition, released on May 19, 2020 for Windows, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One, did not settle the argument. Metacritic rated the remaster "mixed or average." Aggregate scores sit between 64/100 and 70/100, and a later tally of 52 reviews published in September 2024 came in at just 29%. The original's reputation rested on its story, and the remaster's numbers suggest that wasn't enough to carry a second release.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mafia II: Definitive Edition en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q99590361 wikidata.org