Mafia III pairs a standout revenge story with missions that repeat
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A great story inside a dated game
The highest praise for Mafia III goes to its story, and so does the strongest criticism. Alex Donaldson of VG247 called it one of his favorite video game stories of the year. Sam White of The Guardian gave it 2 out of 5 stars and called its mechanics "archaic and desperately unimaginative" while still rating the writing and acting as superb.
Those two reviews disagree about the score, not about the game. Nearly every critic saw the same split: the story, characters and darker themes work, and the moment-to-moment play mostly doesn't. Metacritic rated the reception "mixed or average", and the critic average, calculated from critic aggregates, is 6.5 out of 10.
Lincoln Clay and New Bordeaux carry the game
You play Lincoln Clay, a Vietnam War veteran who comes home to New Bordeaux, a reimagined New Orleans, in 1968. The local Mafia murders his adoptive family, and he sets out for revenge by taking the city's criminal rackets away from the people who run them.
Critics responded to this more than anything else in the game. Marty Sliva of IGN, who scored it 7.5 out of 10, called Lincoln "an incredible protagonist" and said the setting is fantastic in terms of theme. Donaldson also praised the presentation and the soundtrack. Brian Mazique of Forbes gave it 8.1 out of 10 and described it as a character study first.
The city is big. Its 10 districts run from Bayou Fantom to the French Ward, and the map is larger than the Mafia and Mafia II maps combined. Its cars are from the period and handle realistically.
The mission design wears thin
The basic loop goes like this: you attack a location run by the Italian mob, take it over and hand it to one of your lieutenants. You can go in shooting with shotguns and revolvers, call in allies who arrive in a van, or sneak through a whole mission without being seen. There's a cover system, melee combat and executions. Defeated enemies can be interrogated for information, including by scaring them from a moving car.
That sounds like a lot of choice, but critics said the routine barely changes. Sliva called the action "bog-standard" and repetitive. Donaldson described the missions as "by-the-numbers". White's review went furthest, arguing that the game has all the parts of something great on the surface and does little with them underneath.
Sliva's complaint sums up the general mood: a great lead and a great setting that the game doesn't put to good enough use.
Launch problems added to the complaints
Technical problems were the second common criticism. Donaldson pointed to "dubious performance", and the PC version shipped with its frame rate locked at 30 FPS. A later patch removed the cap and fixed other problems, so the PC complaint applies to the launch version more than the current one.
The numbers suggest that critics and players saw it about the same way. Platforms that track aggregate scores put it at 62 to 67 out of 100, and the one with the most reviews counted lists a 66.
Who should play it now
Mazique's Forbes review has the most useful advice for buyers: it's a game for someone who loves a good character study and isn't looking for innovative mechanics. If that's you, the story and the setting are worth the time. If you want an open-world action game with varied missions, the critics' complaints about repetition point to a long stretch of the same work between the parts worth seeing.
- Rated: Mature 17+ and PEGI 18
- Platforms: Windows, macOS, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One
- Mode: single-player only
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mafia III en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20737889 wikidata.org