Mafia's remake rebuilds Lost Heaven but keeps the 2002 game's bones
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fourth Mafia game is the first one, rebuilt
Mafia: Definitive Edition is the fourth entry in the Mafia series, and it goes backward. It's a remake of the 2002 original, developed by Hangar 13 and published by 2K, and its gameplay mechanics come from Mafia III rather than from the game it remakes. That choice shapes the whole thing. The story and the city belong to 2002, while the controls, shooting and driving come from the series' most recent game.
The setting hasn't moved. It's still Lost Heaven, Illinois, in the 1930s, and you still play Tommy Angelo, a Sicilian American cab driver who joins the Salieri crime family, rises, then falls. The original's missions and story arcs carry over. Nearly everything new sits around them.
New assets, a longer story and the series' first motorcycles
Hangar 13 didn't patch the old game. It built the remake from scratch, with new assets and an expanded story. Critics noticed the work most in the cast and the city. IGN gave it 8/10 and praised the new cast's "excellent performances", a "fantastic driving model" and a Lost Heaven thick with 1930s atmosphere. GameSpot was much cooler on the game at 6/10, but it also singled out the story and performances.
Several changes are additions rather than rebuilds:
- Motorcycles, a first for the series, alongside the period cars.
- Classic Difficulty, the hardest setting. It makes ammunition scarcer and has police respond more to crimes, which brings the game closer to how the 2002 version behaved.
- Collectibles based on real pulp magazines of the era, such as Black Mask and Dime Detective Magazine, plus made-up Gangsters Monthly comics and cigarette cards about series characters.
The cards and comics show who the remake is mostly for: people who already know these characters.
Where critics said the old bones show
Reviews split over how much a remake owes the original. Game Informer gave it 5.5/10 and called it "faithful almost to a fault": a glossy finish on a game it found "fundamentally musty" by modern standards. GameSpot's complaint was narrower. It found the combat and movement dated.
Those complaints hit the parts Hangar 13 kept closest to 2002 more than the parts it rebuilt. In those critics' view, borrowing Mafia III's mechanics didn't make the gunfights feel current.
The rebuild changed how Lost Heaven looks, sounds and drives. It changed much less about what you do there.
The aggregate scores land between those two camps. They cluster from 77 to 80 out of 100, and OpenCritic reports that 81% of critics recommend the game. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.9. Buyers showed up too: in its first week it was the third-best-selling game in the UK.
Free Ride got folded together, then filled out
The original had two separate modes, Free Ride and Free Ride Extreme. The remake merges them into a single Free Ride, where you explore the city with no required objectives. Extreme's over-the-top side missions are now hidden in it as secrets to find. The mode was billed as "a nod to the original game".
An October 2020 update gave players more reasons to stay in the city:
- taxi missions
- a racing mode at the autodrome from the "Fair Play" mission
- settings to show or hide parts of the HUD
- Noir Mode, which turns the whole game black and white as a homage to film noir of the era
None of this fixes the combat critics disliked. It does make Lost Heaven, the part reviewers praised most, worth going back to once the story is over.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mafia: Definitive Edition en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q94628102 wikidata.org