MAG's 256-player battles split critics between awe and fatigue
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics agreed on the scale and split on the cost
Nobody disputed what MAG was. It was a first-person shooter for PlayStation 3 built for online battles of up to 256 players, and Guinness World Records gave it an award for "Most Players in a Console FPS". Critics disagreed about whether that scale paid off often enough to make up for everything around it.
At one end, 1Up.com gave it an A− and called it "unlike anything else on PS3". At the other, IGN US complained about bugs, stiff animations, unbalanced factions and too little content and polish for the price. IGN UK listed the same problems.
Most outlets landed in between. GamePro gave it four stars out of five and said a good match was "very, very good", but added that good matches came along only "just often enough" to make the rest worthwhile. GameZone gave it seven out of ten and called it "uneven and eventually tiring". Edge gave it six out of ten, the lowest of the named scores. Across 11 counted reviews the aggregate was 77/100, which gives a critic average of 7.7.
The chain of command is the reason to care
The praise mostly comes back to one system. Players were grouped into eight-player squads, four squads made a platoon and four platoons made a company. Squads were led by players who had moved up the ranking system, and leaders could direct the battle and fight in it at the same time.
GameSpot praised how well the command structure fit into play, even while it complained about technical awkwardness. GameTrailers praised the large multiplayer and called the level-up system inventive.
A later change shows what kind of player the game was built around. Patch v1.05 picked leaders using leadership points, which players earned by winning battles while serving as at least a squad leader, and the selection also considered whether a player had a Bluetooth headset. MAG wanted people who would talk to their squad.
Patient clans liked it, and solo players didn't
Edge described this split most clearly. It said the game's clan support gave dedicated groups a cooperative experience "on a rare scale", but only if they could get through the "unnecessary confusions" and "ungenerous structure" of the early game. For everyone else, Edge said, other team shooters such as Battlefield: Bad Company 2 made the goal clear from the first match.
The progression system explains why the early hours were hard. It was long and tied to a faction:
- Players could level up to 70 within any faction.
- At level 70, Veteran mode let players choose a faction again, but it reset their progress. Medals, ribbons, statistics and leadership points carried over, along with a 10% XP bonus that did not stack.
- Version 2.0 added a skill tree and a supply depot, where players bought weapons with money earned in matches and could sell items back for half the price.
Regular battles counted toward ongoing campaigns between the factions. The one exception was Suppression, the smallest mode, a 32-versus-32 team deathmatch that had no effect on the Shadow War. Even there, players could hold leader positions, but those leaders had no leadership abilities.
For a group that plays together, a good match was the payoff. A solo player joining random matches mostly got the confusion.
What the split means today
The critics' disagreement was really about who was playing. Organized groups with headsets got the coordinated large battles that 1Up.com and GamePro described. Solo players met the problems that IGN, GameZone and Edge described: technical rough spots, lopsided factions and a slow climb before the game felt rewarding.
MAG is now discontinued, and because it was a massively multiplayer online shooter, that makes it a piece of PS3 history more than something to buy. If its squad-based design appeals to you, Zipper Interactive's later shooters are the more practical place to start.
Sources
- Wikipedia: MAG (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q784714 wikidata.org